As per this thread... http://drupal.org/node/view/8433

I have a delimma. Although the work that goes into Drupal is really unbelievable, functions that pertain to a news type or review type site seem slim. Being able to write a news story, a review, etc... requires that you have the ability to have mulipart documents above all else. A review might be several pages long that ends in a rating. A drop down selector with all page titles is also needed. This allows a quick jump to any page in the review. From what I can put together, the only module that allows for multiple pages is the collaboritive book module that doesn't really fit the bill. Article.module allows for links in the blocks to the content, the book module doesn't from what I'm reading. Some multipage function is really needed for the article.module. That or a review module that has this function. It appears that we do have the teaser which is fantastic, but Drupal doesn't seem to have the capability to just add a page to a document. If a page is added to a document, Drupal should be smart enough to add the teaser and resulting pages. This is a real loss. Couple this with multiple hours of searching the site for answers as to why the image.module doesn't work with the latest release, I'm left stumped. Many simple news scripts have the ability to traverse pages. Not being able to place an image on a page and no answers for a fix makes me wonder if there is any hope for Drupal for my needs. It truly is a loss.

Here are my questions:

1) Are there any plans to create an article or review module that allows for page traversal, the ability to add pages on the fly to this article without having to manually order them? If you add a page, common sense should tell Drupal that it's the next page. Not manually configure each page so that you can order the way needed. It needs the ability to just add a page. To me this seems silly to even ask for. Basic news script functions.

2) If the above is a work in progress, will this allow for block links to link to such articles or reviews?

3) Any plans for a working image module? Iv'e scoured the forums and found a partial fix. It didn't however fix the whole issue which is widely known. The 719 we'll call it.

Drupal has many great functions. However, it appears that it's more geared towards a blogger. A Content Mangament System needs more than flexiblity, it needs to work. Without the contributed modules, Drupal core is pretty slim. The contributed modules often have issues with Drupal's core function which makes need for removal of the modules. Without the contributed modules, lack of function. I've resorted to making multiple copies of the article module for review, site news etc... This would give me the ability to hack a single module for multiple paging. However, I'm wondering if I'm missing something. Mabybe I've missed the modules that will do as needed?

If so, please point me to a module that will allow me multiple page authoring. A smart module that I don't have to manually order pages with. That will insert the teaser when a page has been added.

With all the great workings of Drupal, It doesn't appear to be able to turn the page.

Comments

sepeck’s picture

What widely known problem with the image module are you refering too? The image module works on my site just fine. There is work on redoing image handling in Drupal 4.5, you need to scan through Drupal-Dev mail list archives to get a feel for if these efforts will solve your needs. The discussions have been in the last 4 weeks.

Every time I had the 719 error, it was a configuration issue on my part. Generally a directory path issue, type etc. For reference, I am running Drupal on IIS6.

-Steven Peck
---------
Test site, always start with a test site.
Drupal Best Practices Guide

rjspence’s picture

http://drupal.org/node/view/8373

Mr. PHP is as far as I can get. ImageMagick and GD2 are properly installed on a local RH server. I've done everything mentioned and then some. There are also many threads on this. I can retrieve and post all the threads if needed.

Thanks
rjspence

Steven’s picture

You might want to take a look at series.module, which allows you to group nodes using taxonomy and display links to other nodes in a series when viewing one node.

It could be modified to present a page-like interface rather than a floating box.

Alternatively, you could try writing a patch which allows some sort of <!--page--> break to be used. This would need several modifications to node.module though. Maybe you could it through nodeapi, but that would be tricky too.

briandburnham’s picture

I am interested in seeing more news/review site features in Drupal. From my experience with Durpal thus far, I've gathered that:

- Drupal is built on a unique, dependable core

- New features and modules are coming out all the time

- Unless coders or an overwhelming majority of users want a feature, you need to be ready to do it yourself.

I'm just learning PHP, but thanks to the strength of the Drupal core, I won't have to reinvent the wheel. However, polishing and delivering a custom Drupal solution requires rolling up your sleeves.

I think the real solution to your valid complaints is in gathering interested parties and building a Drupal "distribution" like DrupalEd or Drupal4Bloggers. Something along the lines of DrupalPress would be a project I would be interested in helping with.

Brian Burnham
http://brianburnham.com

rjspence’s picture

Hi Brian,

I agree. I think your ideas are good as well. The closest site that I've found that some what delivers daily content is KernelTrap. They put quite a bit of work into it and I do enjoy reading their material on the kernel. One issue they have is why I wrote. When reading KernelTrap you notice that their pages are very long. It seems to be working for them and although they aren't a review type site so to speak, they are a daily content driven site. So really the only aspect of Drupal that I have the issue with is the dividing of content and how it's performed. Setting up catagories in Drupal is great. No doubt the taxonomy is a very powerful way to achieve organization. Easily configurable as well. But as you have several catagories, some will require a shorter length version. When organizing content, pages are the answer. Real long pages are very hard to deal with. A 7 or 8 page review of a topic might very well put your content in a different land. The page would be so long it would drop off the earth.

I've been toying with book.module to see if I could get what I would like out of it. It just doesn't do it. I think it might be altered to where it could do as needed, but with all the function of the article.module, I would prefer this module to do as needed.

I'm not so sure about a "Drupal Distrobution" for a review/news type site. I'm not sure how many people are wanting what I'm asking for. I will say that the civicspace project was developed along these lines to produce a certain type site, but it would really require a few good coders to be involved before this would be the solution.

My post is here, we'll see how many are interested.

Thanks for writing.
Rjspence