Closed (works as designed)
Project:
Drupal.org site moderators
Component:
User account
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Bug report
Assigned:
Unassigned
Issue tags:
Reporter:
Created:
18 Feb 2014 at 15:45 UTC
Updated:
21 Feb 2014 at 05:40 UTC
Jump to comment: Most recent
Comments
Comment #1
nevets commentedThey are not being rude, there are simply trying to understand what you are trying to do.
Comment #2
WorldFallz commentedIt may not be the answer you want, but it only reads as 'to the point' to me, not rude. Jay is one of, if not THE, most prolific development helpers in the forums, which often involves being terse in order to move on to the next post.
Comment #3
WorldFallz commentedplease stop posting duplicate threads and issues-- the dupe issues have been deleted. Duplicates are discouraged and will usually be deleted.
While you may not like jay's answers, they are not rude. Now it seems as if you're crossing over into harassing him. It probably best for you guys to just agree to disagree and move on.
Comment #4
NiklasBr commentedI reported multiple different occasions of him being rude and derailing the thread, they happened to be in the same thread. Sorry about that.
Comment #5
NiklasBr commentedI don't disagree, but this is about his current behavior in this specific thread and not about his awesome past behavior.
Comment #6
jaypanLook. I was just trying to help. In order to give proper help, I need a full picture of what you are trying to do. So I was doing my best to get you to explain the full details, asking the reasons behind what you were trying to do, so I could determine the best method to suggest to accomplish your goals this is what I do. And you for whatever reason didn't want to explain that, then started calling me rude for asking, and in fact reported me for abusive behaviour?!
You were difficult in the thread, rude and thankless for the help I was trying to give, and rude to me. Then you even tried pointing me at the code of conduct which you were in violation of yourself. Well I'll most definitively ensure this doesn't happen again between us by avoiding your threads altogether. I'm not impressed at all.
Comment #7
NiklasBr commentedAll I wanted was to know how to automatically submit a node/add/nodetype form and you kept being rude by derailing the thread by talking about tangentially related topics such as whether or not computers should be allowed to submit forms. All I wanted was the answer to the question "can I use this hook to submit this form?"
If you feel that your rude behavior was warranted, then so be it, but in my seven years as a member of this community I have never met anyone who made me wish I was not part of this community!
Comment #8
jaypanEnough. You've said it 10 times. Obviously I disagree. I will stay out of your threads from now on and we will not have any troubles.
Comment #9
NiklasBr commentedThank you.
Comment #10
WorldFallz commentedI wasn't going to comment further on this thread, but since you took it upon yourself to pursue it via my contact form, I'll reply here.
First, if an issue exists for a topic, the proper thing to do is keep the communication public and not take it to email.
Second, again, I'll say I don't consider anything jay said rude. I don't, period. It may not be the answer you were looking for, but I often find people asking for the wrong solution. Jay was just trying to help you the correct way... Far more valuable than helping you do something incorrectly imo. You didn't agree... As is you right. Disagreement is not being rude.
Comment #11
NiklasBr commentedUnfortunately the thread I created in hope to save the situation and in hopes that it would not spin out of control got locked, which is why I was unable to continue in the thread, my choice was to accept it (but why should I accept someones anti-social behavior) or confront it? When someone does something that is detrimental to the community I, no — all members have a duty to discuss it rather than ignore it.
Once again: Jaypan's behavior was rude because:
Comment #12
NiklasBr commentedI understand that it might seem passive-aggressive to post this link, but in light of his behavior it really do seems that this page need to be read again: https://drupal.org/dcoc
Comment #13
WorldFallz commentedI'm not sure what else to tell you. Two webmasters disagree that jay was being rude. The comment you linked to open this very issue is in no way, shape, or form, even remotely rude.
I'm well aware of the dcoc-- and I don't think jay did anything that violates that.
And duplicate threads are not the solution. Anyone is free to answer your thread-- and nevets was indeed trying to help. Duplicating the thread does nothing but waste resources, make the info more difficult find for others, and lose its history. There's nothing in that thread prohibiting someone else from jumping in if they so desire.
To repeat myself yet again, disagreement is not, in and of itself, rudeness. Jay has stated he won't participate in your threads anymore (your loss imo) and so will no longer be an issue.
Please, lets just agree to disagree and move on.
Comment #14
jaypanI answered your original question in the first post of the thread. Then when you gave more information, I saw that you were trying to do things in an incorrect manner, so I asked for clarification of your overall goal, why you were trying to do it. Your reply:
From the DCOC which you have linked to:
I asked questions to avoid giving bad information, and your response was not responsive nor helpful. So you have gone against the terms of the DCOC there (#1).
I did not accuse you of being ignorant. I'm not sure where you are getting that from, but if you are going to make accusations, you should make sure that your accusations are correct.
As for doing it wrong, I'll quote it again here:
The fact that forms are for user input is not in dispute. Here is a quote form WorldFallz:
So while your claim that I did not give evidence when saying you were doing it wrong is correct, the fact is you were trying to do it wrongly, as agreed with by both Nevets and WorldFallz, and proven with five links all which backed up what I was saying.
Let's look at the original question:
And the very first response in the thread, given by me:
If you look at the documentation for the two functions I gave, both of them do exactly what you asked. So not only did I not prevent the original question from being answered as you claim, I was the answered your question, with additional information on how to do it in D7 so that others who may find the thread would know how to do it in D7 if that's what they were using.
On top of this - how can I prevent your question from being answered? I am not a mod, I cannot lock threads. I cannot control anyone else.
On top of this, we have the following comments from other posters:
And in the thread itself, after you called me rude, I even tried to defuse the situation:
And yet you have still continued to call me rude, opened multiple threads accusing me of harassment, contacted at least one other poster through their personal contact form to complain about me even after they made it clear that they did not agree, made further baseless claims against me, and refuse to drop the issue even when I have tried to drop it, and it's been made clear that people are not in agreement with you.
This is approaching harassment. I suggest you read the DCOC yourself, because I can see that you are in violation of:
1) Be considerate.
You have not been considerate to me at all. I answered your original question, and tried to help you come up with the best solution I could, as a volunteer offering my time and knowledge with no request of anything whatsoever from you.
2) Be respectful.
You have not been respectful. You have called me rude, and disrespected the knowledge that I have of Drupal, that I was using to try to bring you to an effective solution.
3) When we disagree, we consult others.
After disagreeing with me, you opened this abuse thread, consulting others. The two other people in the thread both told you that I was not being rude, and yet you disregard their comments and continue to push your harassment agenda towards me.
If you continue this harassment campaign, I will make a harassment report myself, pointing at this very thread.
Comment #15
kattekrab commentedHi all,
I'm Donna - I chair the community working group. We uphold the drupal code of conduct.
I've reviewed the original thread. I don't feel there was a serious breach of the code here, but I do see frustration and misunderstanding on both sides. And I see you trying to do the right thing by raising the issue, and lay out the situation here.
Thank you.
NiklasBr - Jaypan apologised to you in the original thread.
"I apologize for having worded my posts in a manner that has led you to think I am being rude. It was not my intention."
https://drupal.org/comment/8495411#comment-8495411
NiklasBr - I sincerely believe Jaypan was trying to help you, not be rude to you. I'm sorry you felt frustrated and angry by his attempts to help.
Jaypan - I believe NiklasBr was genuinely seeking help. I'm sorry it wasn't the solution he was looking for, but I'm grateful for your attempt to provide one. Please don't let this stop you from participating in the project.
I don't think there's anything more we can do here, other than remind everyone to exercise a little more compassion, take a few more deep breaths, and acknowledge the limitations of our text based communications. Wikipedia has a guideline to "Assume Good Faith".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Assume_good_faith
Let's try that, and move on.
cheers
Donna
Comment #16
jaypanDonna - thank you for taking the time to take a look at this and giving your comments on the matter.