FNClient-0.6.0 is included with the source. This is :

  1. a violation of our policy on 3rd party materials since this is easily downloadable at fotonotes.net
  2. a possible violation of fnclient's license. The Readme species the OSL license: http://www.opensource.org/licenses/osl-2.1.php

It is currently marked as unsupported.
If somebody wants to make this supported again, licensing need to be sorted out.

Comments

Gerhard Killesreiter’s picture

Project: Fotonotes » Drupal.org infrastructure
Version: 6.x-1.1-beta1 »
Component: Code » CVS
apaderno’s picture

Category: bug » task

The code is still present in CVS.

killes@www.drop.org’s picture

Project: Drupal.org infrastructure » Drupal.org site moderators
Component: CVS » Project/Git problem

we should check if it is still there.

dddave’s picture

Issue summary: View changes

*cough* so?

Homotechsual’s picture

dddave’s picture

Project: Drupal.org site moderators » Drupal Licensing Working Group
Component: Project/Git problem » Violation
kreynen’s picture

Assigned: Unassigned » kreynen

The policy regarding 3rd party code is likely changing. While the LWG is not granting exceptions to include code or assets yet, we are also not enforcing that part of the current policy for code and assets that will likely be granted an expection. In this case, all versions of the OSL licenses are incompatible with all version of the GPL.

As a result this would never be approved and needs to be removed.

I'm going to follow the process @gisle has outlined for the LWG to see how well this works. That process is still being reviewed privately, but a public version should be available for community feedback soon.

Because this project has so little usage and is already unsupported with no future development, this should be a relatively easy issue to resolve.

Homotechsual’s picture

thanks kreynen,

Just trying to see what issues I can clear from the webmaster queue - this seemed like a doddle to check :-)

kreynen’s picture

@MJCO yep. Since licensing issues have ended up in queues all over Drupal.org for years and haven't been handled consistantly, we are very aware that issues like this will continue to emerge from the woodwork for some time. Please keep moving them as you find them!

I think we have a very reasonable, well thought out plan for dealing with licensing and 3rd party code and assets moving forward. Really looking forward to making that public.

gisle’s picture

Assigned: kreynen » Unassigned
Issue summary: View changes
Status: Active » Closed (outdated)

Fotonotes is marked as unsupported, with no packaged release. Last commit was 8 years ago. Closing.

If somebody wants to make this supported again, licensing need to be sorted out.