AddToAny module - create logo

Hi,
Please review.

Thanks

The Twitter logo is outdated, now that they are "X"

Hi,

Please review

Thanks

Will you update both logos?

Hi @volkswagenchick,

Yes, I have updated both logos with latest icon of twitter.

I like add-to-any-logo-2.png, but the logos are too close to the edge and some seem pixelized.

Modified the logo, please verify.

Thanks

I might be mistaken but this new logo is only 350x350 and the requirements are 512x512.

I do like this last logo in comment #8 more than the others FWIW

Hi @volkswagenchick,

The image is 512x512 only, as I have used the canvas of the similar size for designing the logo, also I have cross-verified it using an online tool (posterburner.com and imageonline.co) as well as the image property of the file.

Attaching screenshots.

Please review.

Thanks

Also, when we open the image in new tab from drupal.org, we can see the image attributes (height:512px and width:512px), also cross-verified the same and attaching the screenshot.

Off when I open the inspector it is 359x359....Am I not looking at the right thing?

Thanks

It's quite unusual! Perhaps it's related to the screen resolution. Would you consider checking it using an online tool?

Alternatively, we could wait for someone else to validate this. I've personally tested it using various methods, and the output seems accurate on my end.

It's changing due to the inspector. If we dock the inspector to the right or in a new window we can see it's 512 x 512. Check screenshots.

Thanks @omkar-pd for confirming. I was assuming the same.

@volkswagenchick I am using laptop resolution and as I change the percentages for responsiveness, the image dimensions get changed in the inspector. I am attaching a couple of screenshots to explain the issue better.

As you can see, although I have changed the dimension, but when I hover on the tab, it shows me original dimension i.e. 512x512.

Thanks

Thanks to "Dan Shelton" for tweaking the image from 96dpi to 72dpi.

Uploading. Please review.

Thanks

I think the problem is likely to be the use of the browser's "inspect" function, and in some cases the inspect panel will squeeze the image and force it to scale. In that case the scaled size will be shown rather than the true size, so if using inspect to check, make sure the image is showing at full size.

I don't think altering the DPI is necessary.

I'll prepare previews of the logos later, but I'd have a slight concern about how the many logos in a circle will look at smaller sizes.

Hi @lostcarpark,

Please review these logos.

Thanks

Sorry for the the delay in looking at this. @urvashi_vora has created an impressive selection of options.

Starting with an older one:

I like this one. It's simple and pretty clear. Obviously the Twitter logo needs updating. However it has a clear background, and on dark themes the + sign gets a bit lost. Would it be possible to put the + on a light grey background? I think it would be nice to keep a transparent background separating the boxes.

I like the concept of the logos in a circle, but I feel there too many elements and they are too small.

This one is nice, and I like the idea of more generic sites rather than specific site logos.

This one makes me think of jellyfish. I'm not sure it works as website proxies. However I think I prefer the + on this one to the previous one. So maybe combining the + from this with the speech bubbles from the previous one would be worth a try.

As a design this one looks quite nice, but I'm not really sure what any of the elements represent (except the Drupal logo), so I don't think it really works.

Of these, the first one is my favourite. If the points I mentioned could be fixed, I think it would be spot on.

Confirming that all images are PNG files, the dimensions are 512x512 pixels, and the files are under 10K.

Hi @lostcarpark,

I worked on the suggestions.

Please review.
Thanks

Thanks for the quick work, @urvashi_vora!

I think this one is the best. I think the combination of social media logos with the plus sign makes it very clear, and everything is a reasonable size. This gets my +1.

I think this one is good too. I do think having more generic site icons instead of specific logos has merit, but it does inevitably make it a bit more abstract.

If we can get a few more votes, we should be able to move RTBC.

I dont understand why this isn't just using an adaptation of the official AddToAny logo which is already uploaded to the Drupal project page:

https://www.drupal.org/files/project-images/drupal-addtoany-logo.png

All it needs is to be resized and cropped to 512x512 square.

That's a good point @jwilson3. Looks like they were attempting to make a single representation of the two images on the drupal.org module page

Let's let the module maintainers determine if they like this proposed new logo. Otherwise we'll have to resize the plus sign logo that's on the module page now.

@lostcarpark. what are your thoughts on changing the gray background on the plus sign to the color on the current drupal,org module page? If that can happen on on https://www.drupal.org/files/issues/2023-09-06/add-to-any-logo-1.png then I'm +1 on that logo moving forward for maintianer review.

Hi,

I have updated both the preferred logos, the + with module's color background and the original logo in 512X512 dimensions.

Please review.

Thanks

Thanks @urvashi_vora I'll send both versions from #26 to the maintainer to select from.

Moving to RTBC

Assigned credit and marked as fixed.