The Project Browser Initiative is working on a new page for adding and installing modules. The default display of the Project Browser will show Drupal modules that have a release that is compatible with the version of Drupal the site is using. A card will be displayed for each of the modules (projects). The key components displayed on the card will include a logo, a short description and the categories this module belongs to.
The number of categories was recently reduced from 55 down to 19 to help folks searching for modules to more effectively use the category filter.
First, read through the module’s project page on Drupal.org . If needed, spin up the module on SimplyTest.me or DrupalPod to understand what the module does. Then review the Category Definitions and suggest 1-3 categories for the module. (When in doubt, err on the side of fewer, not more!)
https://www.drupal.org/project/redirect
Comments
Comment #2
chrisfromredfinComment #3
leslieg commentedComment #4
pearcraft commentedOne category is currently listed for Redirect.
1.) Path Management
I see no need to change this project's category.
Comment #5
pearcraft commentedComment #6
leslieg commentedPostponed until a new smaller list of Categories is finalized.
Comment #7
leslieg commentedUpdated the issue summary to reflect the recent change to reduce the number of Categories from 55 down to 19.
Comment #8
tishmgI am working on this one. #Portland2024
Comment #9
tishmgThis one is tough. The previous category of Path Management doesn't seem to fit any of the existing categories. I'm thinking either Site Search or Site Structure, maybe both. Redirects allow users to more easily find content, which seems related to search. But also seems related to content/site structure.
Comment #10
bsnodgrass commentedThis is indeed a difficult one. The old category of Path Management is a better description of what redirect does.
However, our description for the Administration Tools category fits the Redirect module well: Empower site builders and administrators with no-code tools to set up, enhance, configure, or maintain the site.
I do think Search Engine Optimization (SEO) could also be valid.
FYI these are the same categories I have suggested for Pathauto #3277518
I don't think site search works for this one as redirect simply works with URL Alias redirects when the pattern changes, I don't think that is typically considering in Site search.
Editing the Issue Summary, status remains as Needs Review.
Comment #11
lostcarpark commentedWhile the old category, Path Management, does describe the module well, I think that category name was not very helpful to novice users.
I agree with @bsnodgrass that Site Search and Site Structure aren't a good fit. It may help with getting the site visitor to the correct page, but it has very little to do with the actual search process. Similarly, it may help with creating URLs that reflect the site structure, but the module itself has nothing to do with structuring content.
I would suggest making SEO the primary category, since the module helps ensure a single canonical URL for a page, which is an essential part of search engine optimization.
I agree Administrative Tools is also a good fit, but I would suggest making it the secondary category.
Updating the issue summary to swap the order. Keeping at needs review.
Comment #12
bsnodgrass commentedI think @lostcarpark and I are close enough to being on the same page on this one. We will let the project maintainers make their decisions.
Updating the summary and marking RTBC
Comment #13
leslieg commentedGave credit and marked this issue as fixed.