So, I'm talking about http://drupal.org/hosting-support

The guidelines in the sticky at the top of the forum group have been as they are for a while. Those guidelines say that affiliate links and advertising is not allowed.

Where this is grey, and where different posters seem to take a different tack, is whether it's allowed to recommend your own services or not, and if so how oblique it has to be.

Take a recent thread I was trying to help someone in. (http://drupal.org/node/1903276) or a much longer standing thread (http://drupal.org/node/403408) with many posts.

I always err on the side of being very restrained. I don't think it's appropriate to recommend my services in hosting or as a site developer, even if the guidelines allowed it. Others will recommend their own services alongside a few others that they've found to be reasonable alternatives. Others still will only recommend themselves. And then a few will be more blatant, jumping up and down and shouting "use me, use me"!

It would seem there are a range of different views there on what "ads and affiliate links not allowed" means. I didn't want to discuss this issue in any one thread, because threads are usually started by someone looking for genuine guidance, and an in-house discussion on what posts are appropriate becomes like one of those conversations when everybody else forgets that the most important person is in the room. It wouldn't help them solve their problems, find the right providers, etc.

There's another more complex issue here as well, which is when people recommend third party providers. Over on WHT, the policy on this is very strict: Only recommend, or dis-recommend, providers you've actually used yourself. Posters should expect to be asked to prove that, and they often are, and many posts are taken down because they are found to be shills, or shills run by competitors.

So I thought I'd post here, and start a discussion as to what is appropriate behaviour in that forum section. (a) What do people think is acceptable? (b) How actively should that be moderated? (c) Regardless of how actively this should be moderated, what forms of moderation are realistic in a community where the focus is rightly on developing and supporting a platform, not in policing the forums?

Thoughts?

Comments

jamesoakley’s picture

To give another example, this thread (http://drupal.org/node/1942214) is new. Within 12 hours they had had two posts offering help - both from commercial entities offering their services.

Legitimate? Not?

killes@www.drop.org’s picture

I think the last example is fine. The author already mentions that he has a client, so money is already involved.

dsquaredb’s picture

Status: Active » Closed (fixed)

Closing this issue since the hosting list has changed with the D7 upgrade.