I understand that this module is specifically targeted at connecting local accounts with FB accounts.

I'd like functionality to connect the user's session with a FB account, without the need to create a local account.

I'm pretty sure it is possible, but I wonder what specific issues we need to consider in Drupal space (eg, caching).

Is this a feature which could be incorporated into this module?

Comments

xurizaemon’s picture

Issue tags: +fbConnect, +bounty, +facebook connect, +facebook

http://groups.drupal.org/node/57958 is a related request.

If this feature was added to FBConnect (which we'll pay for), then the implementation of the remainder of that job would be pretty trivial.

Implementing this as a feature addition to FBConnect module is actually my preferred solution, as it contributes the functionality back to the community in the most useful manner IMO.

On the other hand, it does shift the scope of the FBConnect module somewhat, so will require the maintainer's acceptance to be rolled into the main module.

(Vectoroc, would be really keen to hear if you'd accept such a patch, assuming the code was quality etc.)

Freso’s picture

Keep in mind that comments are currently all attributed to a user (anonymous comments are attributed to user 0), connecting a Facebook profile to a Drupal site without making a Drupal account, would either mean using the anonymous user, or re-writing the user system.

What would be the purpose of not creating a local account connected to the Facebook profile?

xurizaemon’s picture

Pretty much the use case in the URL above, for a system like the wall background on fixoutlook.org ...

There are a variety of actions a user might want to take after associating their local session with the remote FB auth. This is just one, but I'm sure if fbconnect.module supported the feature generally, many more would come forth.

We don't want to associate these comments to a local user; we just want a table of short text comments with remote identities (Twitter, Facebook), user icon URL, and comment text. I used the term 'comment' generically, not in the sense of Drupal node comments.

I recall wracking my brain looking for a better word to use than 'comment' because I suspected it might confuse, but apparently I didn't find one. I guess I aimed to clarify that in the fourth bullet points (one in each list) - have updated now.

Thanks for your feedback, I do appreciate having had the lack of clarity raised.

Rosamunda’s picture

Hi there!
I´m looking for the same functionality, and I think that for pretty similar reasons.
We´ve a site of our online school, and all students can post comments (drupal comments). They appear with their image and name.
The thing is that anon users can post comments on public articles aswell, and we would like people that often make some comments, but they are not students, to be able to post stuff with their facebook/twitter accounts.

As you can imagine, if all registered users are students, we cannot allow anon people just passing by to have an account. I just want that if they are logged in with their facebook accounts, when they post a comment, to appear with their picture and name.

Thanks!

Rosamunda

honigferd’s picture

I was hoping this module would actually provide a quick sign in with facebook solution - which it doesn't.

I'd love this feature.

ryan.armstrong’s picture

Yea I was hoping for a quick login type situation. Where instead of creating a local account, they could just login with their Facebook account. I would actually like it though if this process created a local account for the user automatically, using their Facebook information to fill in any local account information. Any hope for this?

The idea being that instead of signing up for YET another website, they could just login with Facebook. Of course, in the end they would be signing up for another site since this module would create a local account, but that would really be for the site itself, so that there would be a local user tied to the FB login. But from the users perspective, they would always just be logging in with their FB account.

Rosamunda’s picture

Hm, I think that the alternative for not creating a local account shouldn´t be logging in to the drupal website. Maybe I´m talking nonesense here, but could Drupal just "detect" that the user is anonymous (for the Drupal site) but it has a Facebook account (in FB site), so it just shows the user´s public profile info?
That way the user would still be anonymous, and Drupal shouldn´t log him in.

Again, that´s just my idea of how I would like this to work, maybe isn´t practical, nor do-able.

Rosamunda

honigferd’s picture

Although I think the option of creating a user account is not a bad one - but the new user should only be required to select a username. Also he shouldn't get any of the confirmation mails.

ryan.armstrong’s picture

It looks like the Drupal for Facebook module does this:

http://drupal.org/project/fb

vectoroc’s picture