“Does anyone know how to make Drupal do ‘X’?”
This is a really common question in Twitter. The answer is that there usually is at LEAST one module that does “X”. How do people find modules? How do you know what the best one is? How do you know how it plays with other modules. http://drupalmodules.com/ is a start, but it would be better if Drupal had a way during site building to answer the question, -”How do I make “X” happen?”
The search function on Drupal.Org should let people answer the question, "How do I make Drupal do ...?"
The search results would be organized into groups for each version of Drupal:
1. Ways to do it in Core.
2. Modules that can do it.
3. Support that tells the recommended procedure for implementing the modules (specific for each version of Drupal).
4. Other results.
Module Downloads can be organized by function that the user would be trying to implement rather than by Project.
Example: Modules organized by Catergories like Permissions, Search, Images, etc rather than Views, CCK, Taxonomy, etc.
A simple comparison table that compares how similar modules do similar functions (e.g. Buddylist vs Friendlist) so people can make informed choices.
A way to identify/exclude from search modules which have been deprecated or abandoned.
Comments
Comment #1
drummComment #2
mgiffordI think we should probably close this issue. it was started in 2009. Only other post was from @drumm but was just to move Projects.
I do think this would be a neat idea, but not sure how it would be done. I think we'd need some concrete examples.
It could be that by looking at what people are searching for and tweeting about. There are logs somewhere of Solr searches on drupal.org... Also https://twitter.com/search?q=%22how%20to%20make%20Drupal%22&src=typd
Not sure there is enough content to generalize common questions & promote good answers.
Comment #3
dsquaredb commentedClosing issue since it has been inactive.