reCAPTCHA - Update logo

Just realized I left this on the meta issue yesterday, not this issue. Here's a suggested logo for reCAPTCHA, using Google's logo.

Reviewing as part of Drupalcon Prague 2022

Logo is good, size and format is correct, this is good to go.

@KurtTrowbridge Hey, awesome job! looks very nice, but can you remove the white background? I think a transparent logo would be better than a JPEG image.

Sure—option with transparent background added.

I think it's good to go! Transparent background, dimension (512x512), format (.png) and size (9K) are correct. RTBC if no one else disagrees.

May this logo be used in this project?
Aren't there any restrictions regarding Google's policy?

Good point! Changing status back to "needs review" to check this out.

Here are Google's brand guidelines: https://about.google/brand-resource-center/brand-elements/#product-icons

I could kind of see an argument in either direction, to be honest. They say you can use small icons to indicate integration with Google services, but they also say to be distinct from Google. My inclination is that would be more of a requirement if we were using the reCAPTCHA logo for, say, our own competitive service, but it's a direct implementation of their tool, so I lean toward it being OK. Curious to hear what others think, though.

EDIT: Ha, I see this discussion is happening in the opposite direction (an unofficial logo first, then a suggestion to use the official logo) in the Google Analytics issue, so will keep an eye on that conversation too.

Aside from the obvious potential trademark issues, a concern I have with using the official Recaptcha logo is that the logo relates to the Recaptcha service, not the Drupal module. Using the actual Recaptcha logo may lead to confusion that Recaptcha integrates directly into Drupal or that the module is either supplied by or endorsed by Drupal.

I think having a distinct logo makes it clear that there is a separate Drupal project. If we are allowed to, incorporating elements of the Recaptcha logo makes sense to show that the module uses the Recaptcha service, while giving it its own identity.

I've attached a possible design, which superimposes the Recapthca arrows on the Drupal drop. However, I think careful consideration is required before making a final decision.

You may use small depictions of our Google product icons for educational or informational purposes to indicate that your product or service integrates with, is designed for, or is related to a Google product or service – but you can’t imply affiliation with or endorsement from Google.

As the module is for integration without any affiliation implication, from my perspective, it is ok to use it as the representative icon of the module.

According to the discussion #3282842-23: Google Analytics Project - Update Logo

Logo in #8 is good to be used.

Looks good to me (#8)

+1 LGTM #8

Thanks all, I'm going to mark this RTBC.

Assigned credit and marked as fixed.