Hello,

On the user account page, the country field should either be optional (it is currently required), or it should have an option like "Unspecified" (the current such list item is not a selectable value: the form dont save if that one is selected), "Dont want to specify", "Globetrotter", "Other" or "N/A".

Such an option should be listed at the top to make it visible.

There are various (sometimes temporary) reasons why it is not always suitable to specify a country, so that should be up the users themselves to judge. Having that field required as of now, would either make some people lie and enter false information, or prevent them from editing any of the other fields on that page, as the page will not save without a chosen country.

Simply requiring that field without any flexible option is telling people that d.o. takes it for granted that anyone should be ok with providing this kind of information at any and all times, which strictly speaking comes across as somewhat ignorant and disrespectful.

As I can imagine there are several technical reasons why that field should be required (should have a value), I suggest adding one or more flexible options to the list, for example as examplified at the start of this post.

Comments

Taxoman’s picture

Title: Add option to country listing » Add option to user account country list at d.o.
greggles’s picture

Title: Add option to user account country list at d.o. » Make country profile field optional

I'm not sure why it is required. It may bean old thing nobody noticed before, but I agree it probably shouldn't be fully required.

silverwing’s picture

I'm +1 for making it optional. (We really don't that all that many American Samoa users.)

tvn’s picture

And one more +1 for making the field optional.

dsquaredb’s picture

Issue summary: View changes
Status: Active » Closed (fixed)

Closing this issue. Not specified is an option on the dropdown now.