Hi,

I posted on Ubercart.org but got no response there. I'm the maintainer of the Upsell module. I like what you've done with Recommender - it seems to be really powerful - and was interested in your thoughts in merging this with Upsell. Better yet, I'd like to write Upsell 2.x (for Drupal 6) to utilize your Recommender API, or to at least have that option there.

The main issue I see is that uc_rec kind of goes against the Drupal "way to do things" by more or less duplicating functionality in Upsell. However Upsell uses a store admin-selected list of products to recommend specifically, compared to Recommender which does everything mathematically.

I'm really just trying to figure out what to do - either utilize your API with my module, or dump my module altogether in favor of uc_rec. Thoughts?

Comments

danithaca’s picture

@torgosPizza: yes. it would be nice to integrate uc_rec with Upsell. i'll take a look at Upsell these days and see how we can do it :)

danithaca’s picture

@torgosPizza: i'll mostly focus my attention on improving Recommender API. so it would be nice to make this module part of Upsell. i can try to submit a patch to Upsell after my Google Summer of Code project. or you are welcome to write the code yourself at anytime :) It should be fairly easy to use RecommenderAPI. I'll update its doc soon~

torgospizza’s picture

That sounds like a reasonable solution. I don't want our modules to duplicate functionality, of course, so if yours does things mine doesn't, perhaps we can consider breaking them apart, merging them where appropriate, at least in the sense that they provide two completely different sets of functions for the end user.

I'd love to look at your docs when they are ready. Keep me posted!

jm.federico’s picture

Hi Guys, just checking on the state of this integration. Is it happening?

Cheers

Federico

danithaca’s picture

Status: Active » Closed (won't fix)

The Ubercart Products Recommender module will support Views. So presumably it should get integrated with Upsell through Views?
Marked as "won't fix" now.