It would be nice if some similar modules can be listed so people can evaluate what it is best for their project

For example:

  1. Twig Template Suggester - Adds template suggestions for Forms by form id.

    There is also effort to merge Themable Fields into Twig Template Suggester:

  2. formdazzle! - Adds opinionated template suggestions for Forms, Form Elements, Form Element Labels, and Inputs by form id and field name, with special handling for Webforms and Views Exposed Forms.

    You can see a more detailed comparison here:

Comments

rodrigoaguilera created an issue. See original summary.

jwilson3’s picture

jwilson3
Primary language English
Location Ecuador
commented
Related issues: +#3278319: Feature comparison to themable_forms?

Linking to #3278319: Feature comparison to themable_forms? from formdazzle! issue queue.

mlncn’s picture

mlncn commented
Status: Active » Needs work

Coming over to check if Themable forms wanted to join forces with Twig Template Suggestions. We lean toward pointing to modules like themable forms that do more specific things but it's hard to keep track of multiple modules, such that in 2021 we pushed back on apparent duplicate functionality in #3117738: Theme suggestions for (form) fieldsets per form ID and then this year accepted a merge request that did the same #3217479: Forms do not have theme suggestions. For people not maintaining and contributing to either module, it is presumably even harder to keep track! Especially if the energy to maintain separate modules is lacking, maybe we should merge as was suggested in #3057385: Merge themable_forms into twigsuggest / #3057386: Merge into Twig Template Suggester.

So i think either we document each other and themable forms gets a Drupal 10 release and i'll revert this commit, or a maintainer or two comes over and we join forces?

mlncn’s picture

mlncn commented
Status: Needs work » Needs review

Wow just realizing that what we just committed does not overlap with themable forms after all.

We already do document Themable forms on the Twig suggest module page:

For form elements per element type and form ID, use Themable forms.

Perhaps Themable forms could add this line to its project page:

For form templates per form ID and many non-form template suggestions, see Twig Template Suggester

.

jwilson3’s picture

jwilson3
Primary language English
Location Ecuador
commented
Issue summary: View changes
Related issues: +#3057385: Merge themable_forms into twigsuggest, +#3057386: Merge into Twig Template Suggester

Updated issue summary with suggested documentation changes

ressa’s picture

ressa
he/him
commented

Thanks @jwilson3 for your efforts with comparing the Twig template solutions available, it was really helpful for me to get an overview.

I have added a new "Get more specific Twig suggestions" section on the Working With Twig Templates documentation page.

Feel free to expand, edit it, or otherwise improve it. My aim is to guide people to that page, if they search for "drupal twig template suggestions".