Hello,

I can't make Multilingual support work for my node type Comment:

I'm using the default node type created by the node comments module.

node type settings:

Multilingual support: Enable (without translation)

Extended language support: Extended - All defined languages will be allowed.

Synchronize translations: Nothing, I don't really know what is it.

I don't know if it's a bug or not... Multilingual support works well with others node types.

Any idea?

Thanks :)

Comments

joostvdl’s picture

joostvdl commented

I have the same issue with the 1.x-dev version. Comments aer saved with the default languange and not with the current language.

joostvdl’s picture

joostvdl commented

in #319887: Assign nodecomments to parent language there is a patch for comments that are childeren. But I don't find in any other piece of code that there is support for multiple languanges.

thekayra’s picture

thekayra commented

same issue. subscribing.

Junro’s picture

Junro commented

with another node type, I've got the same problem:

Nodes are displaying with all languages...

Junro’s picture

Junro commented
Status: Active » Fixed

Damm we are still newbies!

You can set a default language filter in your comment view...

thekayra’s picture

thekayra commented

I thought the problem was not being able to select the language of the review. I still have this problem.

Junro’s picture

Junro commented
Status: Fixed » Active

Hum you're maybe right, I don't remember, I will check it again.

thekayra’s picture

thekayra commented

Just to make sure that we are talking about the same thing:

When I create a new comment with 6.x-2.0-beta1, I can not choose the language of the comment and that is possible with 6.x-1.2-rc2.

Junro’s picture

Junro commented

Why not using 6.x-1.2-rc2??

You're problem is not the same ...
You have to enable Multilingual support on the comment node type settings.

thekayra’s picture

thekayra commented

That was the first thing I tried Junro.

If what you meant with Multilingual support was not what I and joostvdl could you explain a little better?

Meanwhile I will open another issue.

Junro’s picture

Junro commented

Ok, i've Comment node module disable since few months. I'm going to enable it again today, and see what was my original problem.

Don't open a new issue, we should have the same problem.

Such a shame this module is not maintained, I really need Multilingual support with Comments.

I was telling me something anyway... Why we should use this module? We can create a node type comment ourself and display it as we want on nodes, using Comment drupal core. Multilingual support will work.

crea’s picture

crea commented
Version: 6.x-2.0-beta1 » 6.x-2.0-beta3
Status: Active » Postponed (maintainer needs more info)

Does the problem still exist ?

crea’s picture

crea commented
Status: Postponed (maintainer needs more info) » Closed (fixed)

no answer

Junro’s picture

Junro commented
Version: 6.x-2.0-beta3 » 6.x-2.x-dev
Status: Closed (fixed) » Active

Hello,

Glad to see this module have a new maintainer! Thanks! :)

I'm coming back to that module. Tested it again.

Multilingual support for node comments stil doesn't work:

Comment content type settings

Multilanguage options:

Set current language as default for new content.
Require language (Do not allow Language Neutral).
Lock language (Cannot be changed).
--> All checked

Extended language support:
Normal - All enabled languages will be allowed.

Synchronize translations:
Comment settings checked

view nodecomments settings

To display only nodes (here comments) in the current language of the site, you have to add a filter:

Nodecomments: Add filters
Node translation: Language
Operator: Is one of
Language: Default site language

That's it. With another content type, every works fine.

But adding the filter below in the node comments view, no more comments is show. I tried many things but It doesn't work.

Why? Maybe it's because we don't have the node/add/comment page like usually. (and it's better like this).

So If you need more informations, I'm here :)

Junro’s picture

Junro commented

No news about this?

Taxoman’s picture

Taxoman commented

Subscribing.

crea’s picture

crea commented
Status: Active » Closed (won't fix)

2.x is unlikely to get any support at this point. Closing all related issues.