CCK fields can only be displayed on comment or parent not both.

I'm not 100% sure that this is a node comment issue, but I haven't dealt with it before installing it and can't find any other instances of it in the CCK or Views issues. I want to display in a view a "title" CCK field that replaces the hidden title field (thanks to auto node title) with its node. I have a content type A that can be commented on by content type Comment. In the view I want the Comments to show the title of their parent type A node. I've created a relationship to the Original Parent NID. If I try to make two fields, one "title" CCK field with the relationship, and one without, it will only display both fields on one node listing. If I use two Node: Title fields everything works fine, with the first field showing on the content type A and the one with the relationship showing on type Comment refering to the title of type A. I would really like to get this to work because I have a third content type showing in the same view that I do not want to have a title displayed with and if I have to display Node: Title it will show for all three in addition to showing the extra title of the parent node for Comments. Any ideas why this is happening?