Closed (won't fix)
Project:
Mobile by Mobify
Version:
6.x-1.8
Component:
Code
Priority:
Critical
Category:
Bug report
Assigned:
Unassigned
Reporter:
Created:
5 May 2011 at 01:42 UTC
Updated:
1 Jun 2011 at 01:47 UTC
jb
MOBIFY STAFF about 8 hours ago
Following is the support request answer from mobify staff. Wish I would have know before spending hrs yesterday trying to track down errors. So far my testing has not shown java to redirect as it is suppose to.
Mobile tools works for theme switch but no caching.
Sorry!
We're working to remove references to the Drupal module as JavaScript is our only recommended and supported deployment method.
Thanks for your patience,
John
Comments
Comment #1
b1tr0t commentedAs noted above, we're discontinuing support for this particular module - but NOT for Drupal!! The recommended way of deploying Mobify on all new sites (including Drupal sites) is to use the javascript redirection method. The javascript snippet for redirection is provided in the 'Deploy' panel for your site in mobify.me. The snippet is unique to each site.
Why discontinue the Drupal module?
1) It doesn't do much. It detects phones based on UA and sends a 302 redirect. The same can be accomplished in javascript making it one less "moving part" to maintain.
2) Given the limited functionality, it's not worth the effort to maintain across all versions of Drupal.
3) Phone user agents are being updated all the time. That means that someone with an older version of the Drupal module has a good chance of not redirecting newer phones. Even worse, we're finding that as the user agent space gets more and more fragmented, there are cases where devices that should get the desktop experience will be sent to the mobile site using the old rules. With the javascript we're able to use our entire device library to do detection (6000+ devices and growing constantly). We can maintain this library actively and there's no need for our users to update anything.
4) Doing server-side redirection can cause potentially serious problems for edge caching services such as Akamai and for some overzealous node caching modules.
Hope that clears things up. Please feel free to contact us directly using our community forum if you have any problems deploying the redirect javascript. You can find the forums at http://community.mobify.me/
Cheers,
Peter
Comment #2
venusrising commentedThis should really be noted on Mobify under your CMS plugin area, its simply shows Drupal Wordpress etc. It is not normal or suggested Drupal practice to need to add java to the head to get something working.
Comment #3
venusrising commented