It'd be great if there was a script that looks in the upcoming queue and finds stories with x real votes (not including fake voters or fake submitters) and does autovoting on them. This would create a real threshold for real voters and a fake threshold for fake voters. It would be good if could be configurable whether it looks at absolute votes (+5 and -2 = 7), just positive votes disregarding negative votes (+5 and -2 = 5), or the total when positive and negative are combined (+5 and -2 = 3).

Comments

mercmobily’s picture

Hi,

Question: could this be done by getting an "autovoting _decider_ user" to vote for one of those stories automatically?

Sounds like a neat solution... The "decider" would be picked randomly... and autovoting would take care of the rest.

Bye,

Merc.

jefflamb’s picture

Sounds good.

I also thought it would be cool to have a "boost" option for admins so you could give a story a boost of a configurable number of votes that would use the fake voters too. For example you might set it to 5 and then when you hit the boost button 5 fake voters would vote for it. Or you could provide a drop down/combo box for admins with values in it between to configurable values (example: 1-5). Then the admin could choose a value and the system would add that many votes to the story using fake voters.

Another idea would be a script that adds a scattering of votes to random stories. This way you don't end up with stories either on only 1 vote or getting voted up and promoted (which looks strange). Otherwise it has to be done manually. There are several ways this script could work. But I think the best way would be to periodically choose x random stories from the queue each hour and add one fake vote to each. x would have to be determined based on the total number of stories in the queue. For example, x could be equal to a quarter of the total number of stories.

Should I make these as separate requests or are they okay here... sorry to be a pain?

mercmobily’s picture

Hi,

--------------------
Sounds good.
--------------------

OK.

---------------------------------------------
I also thought it would be cool to have a "boost" option for admins so you could give a story a boost of a configurable number of votes that would use the fake voters too. For example you might set it to 5 and then when you hit the boost button 5 fake voters would vote for it. Or you could provide a drop down/combo box for admins with values in it between to configurable values (example: 1-5). Then the admin could choose a value and the system would add that many votes to the story using fake voters.
-----------------------------------------------

Developing this involves quite a lot of work:

* An extra field in the DB
* The actual menu
* The ajax to manage that menu
* The actual code to deal with this
* The debugging of this code. Since things happen asynchronously, debugging is a real pain.

The autovoting feature is there to help people get a site off the ground... while it's important for a site not to look dead, I think this would be a huge waste of energy. What you wrote above is basically what autovoting is for - you vote a story with a "magic" user, and that story will slowly get a number of votes.
Yes, it's random. But still...

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another idea would be a script that adds a scattering of votes to random stories. This way you don't end up with stories either on only 1 vote or getting voted up and promoted (which looks strange). Otherwise it has to be done manually. There are several ways this script could work. But I think the best way would be to periodically choose x random stories from the queue each hour and add one fake vote to each. x would have to be determined based on the total number of stories in the queue. For example, x could be equal to a quarter of the total number of stories.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This can be done without any further configuration - just a box that asks how many votes per hour. It still adds a lot of complexity though -- see the autovote code to see what I mean...

---------------------------------------------------------------------
Should I make these as separate requests or are they okay here... sorry to be a pain?
---------------------------------------------------------------------

No worries... these are all autovoting things, so it's better if they stay here.

In the end, the main problem is that the autovoting procedure is so damn complex (with calculating mathematical reminders if the cron isn't run "on time", etc.) that I don't _really_ want to touch it.

Merc.

mercmobily’s picture

Status: Active » Fixed

Hi,

Well, this is done with the current *complete* rewrite of Autovoting.

Bye,

Merc.

mercmobily’s picture

Status: Fixed » Closed (fixed)