Closed (fixed)
Project:
Decisions
Version:
6.x-1.x-dev
Component:
Code
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Support request
Assigned:
Unassigned
Reporter:
Created:
15 Apr 2010 at 21:45 UTC
Updated:
3 May 2010 at 07:40 UTC
I work for a non-profit that holds full membership votes to elect its Board of Directors as well as passing any new by-laws or resolutions.
Last year we were on Drupal 5.x and used the Poll Module. This was a disaster as the module put out the incorrect voting tally.
Is decisions up to the task? What outstanding bugs should I know about? What version should I be using the stable or the dev?
This problem #760386: Result tab shows incorrect results worries me.
Please provide any feedback you can, it would much be appreciated.
Comments
Comment #1
bryancasler commentedI didn't mention it, but we are now on Drupal 6.16
Comment #2
roball commentedI tried the Decisions module (6.x-1.6) for a similar purpose (electronic election of a non-profit organisation's president), but had to realize that is was way to buggy to be used for that. Thus I switched to Advanced Poll. Even if it sill has no official 6.x release, it worked much better for me.
Comment #3
ezra-g commentedThanks for your interest in Decisions. I'd say that the known bugs are documented here in the queue. The one you referenced as a concern has apparently been fixed in the latest dev release.
Advanved Poll is a fork of Decisions and the two are indeed similar. AdvPoll however seems to be largely unmaintained whereas Anarcat and I are at least paying partial attention if not working to review patches and fix bugs here and there.
For more of a comparison of the two modules, you can read http://groups.drupal.org/node/24450 .
Comment #4
anarcat commentedI am of course biased as I am one of the major authors and a co-maintainer of the module, but my opinion is that Decisions is perfectly useable for what you are trying to do. Decisions development is mostly client-driven, which means that critical bugs and real issues *do* get fixed when we stumble upon them in our use cases. So while there are (currently) less features than advpoll, I consider decisions to be more stable and better maintained.
For your specific use case, I can mention the IGDA website (http://www.igda.org/) which has used decisions to hold their board meeting elections. During that project, we finished the Drupal 6 port and fixed a bunch of issues. Then ezra came around and fixed a bunch more, so I believe that, as ezra was saying, all bugs are currently well documented or fixed.
You should therefore look at the issue queue yourself to see if the known bugs will affect you. We will certainly welcome your patches for new bugs or features with wide open arms. :) Also, keep in mind that Decisions is supported by Koumbit.org, which is an long standing contributor to the Drupal community which ensures a long-term support of the project, as opposed to a project maintained only by one or two contributors.
Thank you for your interest in the Decisions module.
Comment #5
bryancasler commentedThanks for the detailed feedback. I'm currently monitoring one post hoping for it to pick up momentum. Because our elections take place over several days, we can not allow the showing of election results after each ballot is cast since this will heavily influence voting turnout and results. Beyond these reasons which could be contested, it is in our organizations by-laws.
#660578: Allow users to override results with display of text
Thanks again for you feedback.