Hi,

I'm fairly certain this is a separate request than what was brought up in this thread (http://drupal.org/node/609888). I'll begin by describing the use case (keep Facebook in mind):

User clicks on their user page.
User page is populated by an activity view containing all the user's "activity" on the website.
User sees a blog, comment or status they posted and decides they want to delete that blog, comment or status
User clicks delete link

The desired result is to have the deletion of both the activity and what it represents (blog, comment or status).

In most use cases I will employ this module the activity always represents the blog, comment or status and should never disappear without the other or vice a versa. So the request is to have a unified (universal) delete handler for activities and what they represent (in this context). I can understand how this may not always be the desired result (there are other use cases) so having either a different handler for just activities or perhaps an admin option to join or separate the two is necessary.

Now, I have tried loading say the delete link for either nodes or facebook statuses in the same activity view but this simply causes other undesired results (such as removing all nodes or statuses from the view). If you think that for whatever other reasons we should try to simply get the other delete handlers all working within one view I'm open to that. I'm just making the ideal request from a user/designer's perspective :)

Thanks,

Thomas

Comments

Scott Reynolds’s picture

Status: Active » Closed (works as designed)

I actually do not like this idea at all. Activity is just an atomic log of things that happen. It has little connection to things outside of itself. It can catch when something is deleted and remove its record and it does that for the standard types (node comment and user).

FBSS for instance, does this as well. When a user deletes their status, the Activity record is deleted.

From a user standpoint I think your feature request would create create confusion. I strongly disagree with this

The desired result is to have the deletion of both the activity and what it represents (blog, comment or status)

The desired result is to remove the Activity from the stream.

pribeh’s picture

Hi Scott, I deeply respect your opinion whatever you choose to do. When I was talking about "desired result" I was referring to the desired result in the particular context of the sites I'm working on. Though really all I am trying to do is to setup an Activity view which can display all delete handlers from each module such as FBSS, Nodes and comments. However, I've had no luck - as I mentioned, adding the "node: delete" field seems to remove display of FBS status' from the view. For now I will rely on FBSS' delete-edit tokens for this. Allowing deletion of statuses from the Activity view is most crucial in my context. As for nodes: it's not a big deal for users to have to click on the link (title) to the node to then gain access to a delete node link displayed on the node's page. Thanks for your thoughts.