Closed (fixed)
Project:
Social Post
Version:
8.x-2.x-dev
Component:
Documentation
Priority:
Major
Category:
Task
Assigned:
Issue tags:
Reporter:
Created:
6 Jan 2018 at 13:49 UTC
Updated:
28 Mar 2018 at 19:19 UTC
Jump to comment: Most recent, Most recent file
Comments
Comment #2
MaskyS commentedComment #3
mashir commentedWorking on this.
Comment #4
mashir commentedPlease check the README.txt file.
Comment #5
MaskyS commentedHello, thanks for the README! It looks great! Just a few minor changes and we'll be ready to go.
Let's put the command on the new line.
This list will inevitably grow, so let's reword this to "Visit {social API Drupal project page link} to find all the available implementers."
We can shorten this link to g.co/gsoc
we can shorten this link to g.co/gci
Also, there are a lot of 80 col violations. Please find them with drupalcs and fix them. (Please see the coding standards.)
Finally, you need to provide a patch that will add the README, not the README itself.
Comment #6
Akanksha92 commentedCreated the patch for README including the few minor changes mentioned above. Followed https://www.drupal.org/docs/develop/documenting-your-project/readme-temp... for the README file. Please review.
Comment #7
mashir commented@Akanksha92 - When a task is assigned to someone, it does not make sense taking it over and also the submitted patch is a blank patch.
Comment #8
mashir commentedAs per your suggestion I have attached the patch for README.txt with all the above changes.
Comment #9
MaskyS commentedThanks! We have a small problem:
Trailing whitespaces.
Comment #10
mashir commented@Kifah Meeran - Removed all the whitespace and attached the patch.
Comment #11
MaskyS commentedLooks good to me now.
Comment #12
Akanksha92 commentedThe patch now applies cleanly. No errors and warnings found. Screenshot attached
Comment #13
mashir commentedComment #14
mashir commentedComment #15
gvsoI'd like to come up with another term than "social network." We have to start showing that the modules are not only related to social networks. A term we have been using instead is "(external) provider"
Running
composer require drupal/social_post:^2.0is enoughComment #16
mashir commentedHi @gvso,
Modified the patch as per the above suggestions. Patch attached.
Thanks!
Comment #17
gvsoThis sentence is still using the term "social network"
Double parenthesis here. It just looks bad.
Just "implementer" instead of "implementer module." Also, still using the term social network.
It should be "Required"
Provide drush command
Maybe "Now you can install modules which are based on Social Post. After
installing implementers, they will be displayed in the Social Post implementer list."
Thanks!
Comment #18
mashir commentedThanks @gvso for your valuable feedback. I am updating the patch and provide your the latest one soon.
Comment #19
mashir commentedHi @gvso,
Patch has been updated as per your suggestions and attached.
Comment #20
MaskyS commentedHello, thanks for the hard work. Great to see this issue almost fixed. Here are a few things I found:
with all the dependencies,*
should be "using the drush command:"
can we replace the first line with "To post to different external provider services, you need to install the respective Social Post implementers"? That sounds better to me.
Wrong link.
Comment #21
mashir commentedHi @MaskyS, @gvso,
- I guess the link is correct. As you can see all the available implementers for this module from that link.
So do I need to remove that line or need to change the url? Please suggest.
Comment #22
mohit1604 commentedFixing points 1, 2 and 3 mentioned in #20.
Comment #23
mohit1604 commentedThis should be fine, fixing points 1,2 and 3 as mentioned in #20.
Comment #24
mashir commentedHi @MaskyS,
I have added first 3 points into the patch (#24) as you suggested in comment #20, and for point 4 I have added comment on #21 for your suggestion.
Comment #25
gvsoThanks everyone!
I feel like this sentence sounds weird. There should be a "to" after autopost and I think the word "services" is unnecessary.
"To post to external providers, you.."
Change it to /social_post
Comment #26
mashir commentedHi @gvso,
Thanks for your feedback. I have attached a new patch with all your suggested points in #25.
Comment #27
krina.addweb commented@Mashir, Thanks for the patch, But I need some more corrections in it. i.e.
> Change all URLs to Breadcrumb As per the ReadMe Standards described & shown in https://www.drupal.org/docs/develop/documenting-your-project/readme-temp...
> Check for the 'Text manually word-wrapped within around 80 cols.'
Can you please do the needful!.
Comment #28
gvsoThanks! We are almost there
It should be plural: "providers"
Also, follow @krina.addweb's feedback and remove all references to the term "social network"
Comment #29
dhruveshdtripathi commentedDid changes mentioned in both #27 and #28.
Comment #30
mashir commentedHi @krina.addweb, both your suggested points are added in new patch [All the URL's into Breadcrumb and around 80 characters in each line].
@gvso - I have changed it.
Patch (#30) has been attached.
Comment #31
ankitjain28may commentedThe patch in #29 is not fulfilling all the requirements.
The patch in #30 is almost as per the requirements except this-
Need to remove all reference to the term "social network" as per the comment #28
Comment #32
mashir commentedHi @ankitjain28may, Thanks for your feedback. The suggested changes has been implemented to the new patch (#32).
@gvso - Latest patch has been attached (#32).
Comment #33
ankitjain28may commentedThanks @Mashir, Patch is applied cleanly and as per the requirement. Let @gvso review it too.
Comment #34
MaskyS commentedThanks everyone.
The "." should be replaced with ":"
Looks like we're missing a space here, should be "Go to". Also, can we remove the colon?
I apologize, "their respective" would be more fitting here
Could we remove the colon?
remove the colons here too?
Other than that this looks perfect to me. Thanks again!
Comment #35
mashir commentedHi @MaskyS, All changes has been resolved in the attached patch (#35).
@gvso - I guess no need to change anything for now in README.txt. Please review once.
Comment #36
MaskyS commented@mashir See #34 No. 3
Comment #37
mashir commented@MaskyS - As i believe that the term "their" is meaningless. If you use "their" term than it indicates to whom, so I guess it will better to remove "the" and "their" from that line (what I did in patch #35). So the line will be simply:
To post to external providers, you need to install respective Social Post
But if you really want to add "their" then I will add it.
Comment #39
gvsoI added "their" in that line.
Thanks everyone!