Please start with the related issue, 2491439. I've since found other issues with the same setup.
Use case: I want all my Internal people (e.g. staff) who are assigned to committees, to have the ability to edit all Document Pages in any Sections within the top-level "Internal" Space and its Sub-spaces.
Structure recap:
- Startup Committtee Group (user Alice is a member; Settings: Sub-groups inherit members, use child permissions)
- Everyone Group (no direct members, inherits members from Start-up Committee Group; Settings: Sub-groups inherit members, Inherited Permissions)
- "Internal" top-level Space (Private; no direct members; inherits from Everyone Group; Sub-groups inherit members, use child permissions)
- Start-up sub-space (Public; no direct members; inherits from Internal; Sub-groups inherit members; use child permissions)
1. First, I edited the "Everyone" Group, which has only inherited members, and selected "Inherited Permissions" and "Override defaults". I then added the "Edit any Document Page" permission to regular members, via the group permissions config page.
Expected: This would allow any member of the Start-up Group to edit any document page in the Start-up sub-space.
Observed: No, the permission was not inherited.
2. Then I tried editing the Start-up Committee Group directly, making the same changes to it as I had to the Everyone Group, with the same expected and observed results.
3. Then I made the same changes to the Internal Space, with the same expected and observed results.
4. Finally, I added user Alice as a direct member of the Internal Space. This time, she correctly inherited the permission to edit any Document Page in the Start-up sub-space.
I believe cases 1, 2, and 3 are bugs. Please let me know if I can provide any more detail, or if you'd like me to test anything on this setup. Also, if there have been changes made to permissioning since 2.40-rc1, please let me know, and I'll repro on a 2.41 clean install.
Thank you! Happy to help make a great product better.
cheers,
Jake
Comments
Comment #1
mpotter commentedI think the main problem with all of these issues is that you have the inherited permission option set to "child permission" instead of "inherited permissions"
When you use "child permission" then the permissions of the parent space or group are ignored and the user is just considered a normal member of the space.