Believe this is a bug in the inheritance of space visibility, since most everything else works as expected.
Repeating my setup description from another thread...
In real life, I have teamslet's call them committees, for the sake of not overloading another word.
- Start-up Committee
- Fundraising Committee
I also have a committee of Everyone, which is just the union of all committees.
In Open Atrium, I have created
- Start-up Group, with members directly added
- Fundraising Group, with members directly added
- Everyone Group, no direct members, but inheriting members from Start-up and Fundraising Groups.
I have created a top-level private Space, "Internal", with no direct members, but have added the "Everyone Group" to the "Inherited" tab for the Internal Space. "Internal" then has several Sections and several Sub-spaces with their own Sections.
All Groups and Spaces have the settings
- "Yes - subgroups should inherit users."
- "Use Child's permissions"
- Default roles and permissions
What I've just noticed is that, even though my individual members of e.g. the Start-up Group have access to view and create content in the "Internal" top-level Space (and its Sub-spaces), "Internal" does not show up in the list of Spaces in the OA toolbar menu, nor does it appear in the list of "All Spaces" for those users. The only way they can navigate is through a deep link, or by using the Site Map (where all Spaces, Sub-spaces, and Sections appear as expected.)
Expected: full membership in the top-level "Internal" Space via inherited membership through their Group, as though they were a regular direct member.
Comments
Comment #1
mpotter commentedThis is a known issue with the Spaces page. It only shows spaces with direct membership and not spaces accessible via inherited membership. This is on the roadmap to improve this summer.
The toolbar shows "recent" spaces, so once a user has visited the space for the first time then it should appear in the drop-down menu. When there aren't any "recent" spaces it only shows top-level public spaces or spaces the user is a direct member of.
Part of this is "by design". Atrium makes a distinction between membership "access" that can be inherited, vs direct membership. On most sites, users will have "access" to many many spaces but only be directly interested or participating in certain spaces. We are working to improve this so users can mark their "active" spaces even if they are just inherited members.
Until then, all you can do is have people visit the URL directly the first time to get it into their Recent list (or then Favorite it to get it into the Favorites list). Or you can add a link to your Main Menu for the Internal space and it should show in the banner section for users that have access to it.