pcambra’s picture

Features integration for Shipping is in the scope of this module, could you please specify what components you can't export?

Everett Zufelt’s picture

I am using commerce_flat_rate, the services that I have created for this shipping method, and the associated rules, do not appear to be exportable.

Haza’s picture

Status: Active » Needs review
4.16 KB

Should we change the title to "Commerce flat rate exportable with commerce features" ? or something like that ?

here is a patch to allow commerce_flat_rate (and only that) to be exported in commerce_features.

Haza’s picture

Forgot to reset the shippings_services when we rebuild the features (the methods don't show unless we clear cache)

pcambra’s picture

Status: Needs review » Needs work

I'd rather see a generic shipping export instead of having a file per service.

bojanz’s picture

This is #4 + the same fix I added to other files in #1572330: Don't cause excessive cache and menu rebuilds.

I will reroll to address feedback soon.

Haza’s picture

Another try. Changed the default hooks used, from 'commerce_flat_rate_default_services' to 'commerce_shipping_service' and also add a key in the export that is generated to be able to identity this export as a features one. (that will help in an other path for commerce_shipping to not throw some code if we are importing a features - but not sure this is a correct approach)

glennpratt’s picture

This is just a re-roll of #6 because I couldn't get it to apply to rc1 or dev. Works fine.

I couldn't get #7 to show my shipping rates for export in a quick test, sorry I don't have any insight - it easily could have been my mistake.

ponies’s picture

Applied #8 to dev and tried to export two flat rates. The components weren't exported. I'm using features 2.x.

pcambra’s picture

Title: Commerce shipping exportables with commerce features » Commerce shipping flat rate exportables with commerce features
Status: Needs work » Needs review
fearlsgroove’s picture

It'd be a great start to supporting config management shipping generally if this approach would track all shipping method rules as well.

GuGuss’s picture


GuGuss’s picture

Works fine.

Ready to be Committed !

nadavoid’s picture

Issue summary: View changes
Status: Needs review » Reviewed & tested by the community

I can confirm that #8 works for me too.

introbay’s picture

#8 works for me too.

sharpbites’s picture

Any plans on making commerce shipping rules components exportable?

roland.molnar’s picture

Status: Reviewed & tested by the community » Needs review

I have tried the patch #8 but ran into a problem when using in conjunction with commerce_free_shipping.

By default, it exports the rate's callbacks like this:

      'callbacks' => array(
        'rate' => 'commerce_flat_rate_service_rate_order',
        'details_form' => 'delivery_details_form',
        'details_form_validate' => 'delivery_details_form_validate',
        'details_form_submit' => 'delivery_details_form_submit',
        'original_rate' => 'commerce_flat_rate_service_rate_order',

But if I enable commerce_free_shipping module and turn on free shipping calculation for the flat rate service, and export it using features, the 'rate' callback will change from 'commerce_flat_rate_service_rate_order' to 'commerce_free_shipping_rate_callback'.

      'callbacks' => array(
        'rate' => 'commerce_free_shipping_rate_callback',
        'details_form' => 'delivery_details_form',
        'details_form_validate' => 'delivery_details_form_validate',
        'details_form_submit' => 'delivery_details_form_submit',
        'original_rate' => 'commerce_flat_rate_service_rate_order',

Installing the feature module with this setup will cause a infinite loop, calling commerce_free_shipping_rate_callback( ) on the /checkout page.
I am not sure if the problem is with the exporter or the module commerce_free_shipping.

paulihuhtiniemi’s picture

I can export flat rate service initially, but after that I can't update that service anymore. For example, changing base rate via UI is impossible.

samspinoy’s picture

Exporting the flat rate works, but features doesn't seem to recognize when the config has changed. If you recreate the feature anyway it does reflect the changes though (e.a. it exports correctly).
Also, reverting needs to happen through drush with the --force argument because features doesn't recognize the config has changed.

carletex’s picture

The name of the default hook and the function mismatched. Also, the rules componentes were being exported for unexisting shipping services.

mqanneh’s picture

Status: Needs review » Reviewed & tested by the community

patch #8 worked for me

grisendo’s picture

Status: Reviewed & tested by the community » Needs review

Patch #8 doesn't work correctly as #17 #18 #19 report. It doesn't work for me also.

#20 explains why, and proposes a new patch, which works for me.

So, reverting back to "Needs review" and let's go all to test the patch at #20

Anonymous’s picture

Status: Needs review » Reviewed & tested by the community

Patch #20 did the job for me, thanks guys..

meecect’s picture

Looks good, but is it possible to include the flat rate description or title in the exportable in the features display instead of the display name (or in addition to the display name) ? Right now I have a bunch of shipping rates based on location, but they all have the same display name 'standard shipping', and then I have a bunch of similar rules for 'express shipping'. In the feature creation page, all these rules look the same.

I think this is a common use case, because the consumer just wants to see 'standard shipping' or 'express shipping', but the rules may be more complicated and the developer probably should see the rate 'title' on the features page. I don't necessarily want the shipping rate name shown to the user to be 'standard shipping to AFO/APO', 'standard shipping to continental US, except Virginia', etc.

meecect’s picture

It looks like the service name is set on line 32 of

changing it to:

      $feature_types[$service['name']] = $service['title'];

fixes it for me.

There are a few options:

$service['title'] => title in admin interface
$service['name'] => machine name
$service['display_title'] => user-facing name

It seems to me like $service['title'] is the appropriate one to use here, since the feature creation page is an admin-centric page and should use the admin-centric name.

a.milkovsky’s picture

I can confirm that #20 works. Thanks! +1 for RTBC

  • mglaman committed 4f012ae on 7.x-1.x authored by carletex
    Issue #1402762 by Haza, carletex, bojanz, glennpratt: Commerce shipping...
mglaman’s picture

Status: Reviewed & tested by the community » Fixed

Thanks everyone! It's in.

Status: Fixed » Closed (fixed)

Automatically closed - issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.