Hi everyone!
my name is Tomaz Zaman and I'm a part of an early stage startup called Carmivore. This project is all about enhancing the IRC experience for people on various popular IRC channels on Freenode network, including those, owned by Drupal. Because we need some data to operate on, we would place a bot on each channel. There it would analyze the data (logs would not be shown publicly) that we could use as a base for our project. The main goal of this project is to give people a chance to promote themselves by helping others and being an active part of the community. This bot initially tracks what you may know as Karma points, which are then displayed on the website (http://carmivore.com). It also tracks other activities which will later be used to enhance this service even more. And don't worry, we respect your privacy so no other information than your nickname will be displayed (unless you'll allow us to by registering once that is done).
Thank you!
Tomaz
Comments
Comment #1
chx commentedI talked to Tomaz and he said he has talked to the freenode staff whom were OK with this. Given he could do this, easily, without anyone being the wiser and his bot got a cloak (ie static hostmask) should a specific channel want , they could keep the bot out. I do not see a problem here, really.
Comment #2
damien tournoud commentedYep, no problem from me either. That sounds like a fun service.
Comment #3
schnitzel commented+1
Comment #4
gddI am fine with this too, as long as the logs aren't made public. I'm sure there is lots of fun data to be mined.
Comment #5
skwashd commentedI'm just a user, but I thought I'd chime in. This appears to be more thought through than the last IRC startup I came across on freenode - IRCSeek. I'm be interested to see how this goes.
Comment #6
skwashd commentedRemoving accidental tag - too tired. I read tag as title. #fail
carmivore++
skwashd--
Comment #7
DjebbZ commentedCheck http://druplicon.info. It's a Drupal project, they already have some logs, they track Karma, all integrated with Drupal. You may want to contribute to the project instead of starting your own, but I don't know how it's maintained to date.
Comment #8
heine commentedWhat activities?
Huh? Aren't you displaying Karma (and later other activities) with the nickname?
Is it also possible to register to opt-out entirely? Or perhaps, opt-in to the tracking?
Comment #9
gerhard killesreiter commentedI'll certainly kickban such a "service" from #infra.
Please announce the name of your bot here.
Comment #10
carmivore commentedDjebbZ, we have checked the druplicon bot, but we have quite a lot of different plans for our service, the Karma tracking was only set up to bring some traction to the project and will only serve as a base, on which it will be expanded.
Heine, activities like frequency and usage of some words (depending on the channel), frequency of communication on channel for each user,...
Yes, it will be possible to opt-out entirely, however we are only contacting channel operators who will opt-in on behalf of their members.
Obviously contacting each member individually would be a long process and some prefer not to be bothered at all. This is the reason we chose this route.
Thank you for your input!
Comment #11
manarth commentedI can see value in what's being proposed. It'd be good to see data like 'busyness' of channels, maybe average karma level, etc.
However, I'd also like reassurances on anonymisation, data-retention (for example, removing records older than 6 months). I'd like to see a published privacy policy, and information on data-protection governance (i.e. is it a Slovenia company, therefore subject to Slovenia/EU data-protection laws? Is Carmivore registered as a data controller?)
Comment #12
chx commentedGerhard, the bot is carmivmor@unaffiliated/hardfu/bot/carmivore .
Comment #13
carmivore commentedmanarth, thank you for your input!
Currently, the privacy policy is still being written and will be uploaded once done. We just wanted to get the bot online as soon as possible, which will give us some time (and gather the needed data) to work on non-technological aspects. We do not see any harm in that because everyone with a bit of technical skills can write a logger script for their favorite client and log the data without anyone even knowing. Being the freenode community member for almost 10 years, I wanted to get it done properly so I decided to work on this hand in hand with you guys. As chx pointed out, the bot can be kicked (and banned) at any time, should you feel exploited in any way.
As I said, we're at a very early stage (meaning there is little funds in this), so legal issues are still being worked on. However I can assure you, those will get sorted out as soon as possible.
Carmivore is not registered as a data controller.
Comment #14
lizzjoyHi @carmivore, I am closing this issue due to inactivity. Please open it again if you wish.