I posted this ...

http://drupal.org/node/1353906

in the draggable views feature request queue.

"I'd like to suggest that draggable views merge in the functionality from the sgrid or sortable grid module. The database schema is functionally identical and sgrid could be a sub-module of draggable views. That way, draggable views could have two sub modules ... "draggable table" and "draggable grid" with corresponding display types. I'd be happy to fork the sgrid code into dviews 2.0 if everybody is ok with it?"

It would just be clearer for users to have this functionality all in once place, especially since they are both views plugins that do drag and drop ordering. Thanks for your consideration.

Comments

Countzero’s picture

Assigned: Unassigned » Countzero
Category: feature » task
Status: Active » Postponed (maintainer needs more info)

Hi and thanks for your proposal.

I agree this merge could make sense. I created Sgrid in the first place because Draggable Views (DV) didn't provide this functionality.

I don't have any problem with this, on the principles level. I see several concrete problems though :

- First, and mostly, we would have to wait for DV's maintainers answer, of course.
- I'm not sure they'll be intesrested, as there were demands for this functionality in several places, and they never got answered. Maybe it's a time issue, but it also may be that the maintainers don't think it fits with DV's goals. We'll see what they say about this.
- I'm not sure myself Sgrid functionality really fits that well with DV's. It was intended to provide a simple lightweight module with a friendly interface and an easy setup. It's much more modest in its goals and the way it is implemented than DV.
- Code quality is probably much lower than DV's too.
- There are bugs in Sgrid which should be solved before anything else takes place.
- Maintaining a separate module and becoming a co-maintainer on an existing module are two very different things, and I'm not sure I'd agree to endorse the duties implied by a collective work. Not because I don't agree with the concept, but because I'm not sure to have enough time available to not hinder the other people involved.

There may be other issues, but will see where the conversation leads us.

ygerasimov’s picture

Status: Postponed (maintainer needs more info) » Fixed

Thanks to 1359304 we have implemented draggable grid functionality in draggableviews 7.x-2.x. Welcome to test!

Status: Fixed » Closed (fixed)

Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.