This module is absolutely awesome! I was searching something like that for a long time. I'm surprised to see only a few sites use it yet.
The only thing I miss is a few customizations like size and background colour of the input box and also a way to prevent the page being scrolled down too much (it hides the "Post a comment" title).

Really nice work, Thanks for this module!

Comments

bboldi’s picture

bboldi commented

Thanks for positive critics, and for sharing your ideas! I have plans for extending the module, but unfortunately (or fortunately) I don't have much free time lately ... I will update the module as soon as I have a little extra capacity ;) !

havabeer’s picture

havabeer commented

Hi, another improvement request would be to inactivate the minimalist text box in Edit mode.

Many users have complained that they cannot edit their comments. After investigating I found out that it is because when they click the Edit link, they are shown a small blank box and think there's something wrong. If they were to only click inside the text box, they would see their content and be able to edit it; however many people don't realize this and give up. I have to admit I found it confusing the first time as well.

Since there's really no aesthetic value to the reduced text box in Edit mode, it would be best not to show it in the first place, and avoid the confusion from first-time users.

Thanks for the nice module.