http://www.trellon.com/content/blog/looking-few-good-people

who mails them with request to stop posting hiring to d.o/planet?

Comments

bertboerland’s picture

Assigned: Unassigned » bertboerland
Status: Active » Fixed

mhaggerty contacted me. case closed

greggles’s picture

who mails them with request to stop posting hiring to d.o/planet?

$You do, where $you is the reporter.

Be nice to the people, the rule about job posts is new and many old time planet members don't know it.
Give them alternates, point them to an issue about creating an alternate feed (currently unlikely to gain steam) and the Groups.Drupal.org jobs area.

bertboerland’s picture

mhaggerty contacted me. He wasnt too pleased -rightfully so- since he didnt knew about the new policy and this isue made him look bad. Not meant that way. Will write blog post about new policy to make sure this will not happen again in the future.

bertboerland’s picture

tried to explain it here http://willy.boerland.com/myblog/the_whole_planet_is_hiring no harm ment to trillon or others

Anonymous’s picture

The basic issue I had is the fact this is all being handled publicly. The issue queue is indexed by Google and items like this can come up in search results with little or no context. Having webmasters come to my blog and post comments saying this post abuses some policy I never even heard of compounds the problem.

A better way to handle issues with the quality of content in Planet Drupal may be to keep issues like this private. For instance, there is no public issue queue for vulnerabilities identified by the security team because those issues have no reason being public. Similiarly, there is just no good reason to mass communications about infractions of the Planet ettiquette policy in with the rest of the body of conversation about Drupal. Everyone will get the message eventually about posts on the Planet if you simply email participants and follow the stated rules.

alex ua’s picture

FYI- I added the following to get some clarity on this subject. #958318: Remove text about "what is not welcome on Planet Drupal" from /about/drupal-planet

I think Trellon should feel free to post Drupal jobs on the planet if they want to. They post plenty of good content, contribute tons of code, sponsor all sorts of event at great cost to their company, and have been around/supporting the community for years.

dave reid’s picture

I encourage webmasters to contact the blog owner privately and also post an issue here, not comment on the actual blog. Handling Drupal Planet issues is not the same as vulnerabilities, please. They should be handled in the webmasters queue as everything else is. As long as we are clear and reasonable on the action that should be taken, I don't think it hurts anyone by filing the issue and the feed owner is responsible in fixing the issue. It shows they are responsive and a good community member.

greggles’s picture

Title: trellon is hiring post on planet » An instance of hiring posts in the planet

It's standard in the community to handle things publicly. In part we handle things publicly in case there are repeated problems so we can point to the warning.

That said, there's no reason to be punitive in the long run for an honest mistake and we can also reduce the SEO of this node so it no longer draws unwanted attention...

Status: Fixed » Closed (fixed)

Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.