Motivation

I wasn't aware of this module until today and even though it appears to have quite a significant number of adopters, it's not quite so many as Menu Per Role and I am interested to hear of others' views comparing the two.

Comments

SirClickALot created an issue.

jagraj_singh_gill’s picture

jagraj_singh_gill commented

As per my understanding, versioning of Drupal core plays a key role here. Menu Per Role doesn't have a stable release for Drupal core versions below 9.4. Additionally, it lacks the ability to inherit the Parent's visibility settings on Child menu items.
So, these seems to be the good reasons to go for Menu Item Role Access

sirclickalot’s picture

sirclickalot
Primary language English
Location Somerset
commented

My question is all the more relevant today I think becase both modules have a stable Drupal 11 release.

Could I please ask the module maintainers to comment here as I am very interested as to why both are being maintained.
I am considering moving to this one if for example, perhaps it operates more efficiently?

Thank you

liampower’s picture

liampower commented

@SirClickalot I am unable to answer your question as I have never use the Menu Per Role module.

From #2:

Additionally, it lacks the ability to inherit the Parent's visibility settings on Child menu items.

Seems to be functionality that has previously been called out that differs.