Postponed (maintainer needs more info)
Project:
Drupal core
Version:
main
Component:
base system
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Plan
Assigned:
Unassigned
Issue tags:
Reporter:
Created:
2 Feb 2021 at 09:40 UTC
Updated:
5 Oct 2026 at 06:58 UTC
Jump to comment: Most recent
Comments
Comment #3
aaronmchaleThere's probably a pretty strong use case for: Media, Media Library, Content Moderation (maybe?), Layout builder (maybe?).
What even is Standard for these days, it feels a bit like a vague profile with no specific direction as to what it's supposed to contain. Should we have a separate profile for content focused sites that includes Media, LB, CM, etc? Should we have a profile that's designed as a blog/personal site starting point? There's some really great profiles in contrib, could the Project Browser initiative one day allow us to have a curated set of contrib profiles right there in the installer? If all or some of those happen, do we reach the point where the standard profile itself is removed?
(Mostly rhetorical questions, trying to spark some ideas).
Comment #4
longwaveGiven #3158669-2: [policy, no patch] By default deprecate non-experimental modules that are used by less 5% of sites before the next major version I think there is a definitely a strong case for adding Media to the standard profile - 32.5% of sites have it installed anyway. There is probably also case for Responsive Image with over 26% of sites having it already.
I also think there is a case for removing RDF and have worked on #3243121: Remove RDF module from the Standard profile for this.
Comment #5
joachim commented> I think there is a definitely a strong case for adding Media to the standard profile
If Media isn't in the Standard Profile, doesn't that mean that the Article node type set up by Standard uses a plain image field, which is directing people down a site structure pattern that we shouldn't be recommending?
Comment #6
longwave@joachim good point - to me that is an even stronger reason for adding Media to the standard profile, and reconfiguring the article image field to be a media entity.
Comment #7
joachim commentedShould we made a child issue to specifically convert the article node type to use media? I feel that this issue is more of a strategic thing that's clearly taking a while, whereas encouraging people to use image fields instead of media should be done a bit more urgently.
Comment #8
longwave@joachim sure, this is a "plan" issue anyway, these don't usually get committed directly but work happens in child issues.
Comment #9
quietone commentedAdding some related.
Comment #10
xjmThe objective of the "Easy out of the Box" initiative is to make Layout Builder, Media, Media Library, and Claro feature-complete and part of Standard. So I think we should leave that out of scope here for now; it has an entire initiative.
Comment #11
xjmFor reference, here's the list of what's in Standard, and their usages as of 2020 from #3158669: [policy, no patch] By default deprecate non-experimental modules that are used by less 5% of sites before the next major version.
If site owners have gone out of their way to turn a module off, that might be an indication that it doesn't belong in Standard (even if it does belong in core). A couple thoughts:
Usual caveats blahblah about how this is based on
update.moduledata etc.Comment #12
xjm@joachim, re:
I'd suggest looking at the #2825215: Media initiative: Roadmap and adding your thoughts there if they aren't already covered.
Comment #13
effulgentsia commentedFor easier scanning, here's the ones from #11 that are below 80%:
I don't think that popularity should be the only factor, but I do think each of these should be evaluated for whether we think they're important to keep in Standard or in core at all. We've already done that for RDF in #2152459: [Policy] Deprecate RDF module and move it to contrib.
Comment #14
catchColor module has issues at #3090894: Replace color module with a CSS-Variables based module to provide configurable theme parameters and #2808151: [policy] Move the Color module to a contributed project when Bartik is deprecated.
Comment #19
quietone commentedIs any more discussion needed here?
List of extensions added and removed since this issue was opened.
Added
Removed