I have had a rather unpleasant encounter with a long time user of Drupal.org.
He was reported as a spammer by other users for posting self-promotional material in the Paid Services forum. The sticky for that forum clearly says (in bold letters):
DO NOT start a thread or comment on a thread with an advertisement of your services, request that the poster contact you, …
I routinely examined his posting history and found that user had violated both rules multiple times within the last 48 hours:
- He had started a thread with an advertisement of his services.
- He posted comments where he had requested that the poster contacted him.
However, his previous posting history came up clean.
I sent him a PM using his contact form with a link to the forum sticky and asked him to read the rules. I also pointed out the problematic posts, and asked him not to do this again.
Shortly afterwards, I received this reply by email (redacted, as this is a public facing forum):
**** you, stupid *******, unbelievable, put your rules in your ******* ***.
For the record, after receiving the warning, he has not posted any more self-promotion in an inappropriate place (so far).
My first impulse upon receiving the profanity-laden rant was to block this user.
However, on second thought, maybe that is a bit extreme? He probably didn't read the sticky before posting, and he then threw a temper-tantrum when he received my warning about this being inappropriate.
I am still learning the ropes here. Advice from more experienced webmasters about whether to block this user (or not) will be appreciated.
Comments
Comment #2
volkswagenchickhttps://www.drupal.org/about/values-and-principles
Principle 8: Every person is welcome; every behavior is not
Principle 10: Seek first to understand, then to be understood
Perhaps you can direct this user to the above values.
Comment #3
gislevolkswagenchick,
thanks for chiming in! Good advice.
Comment #4
mmjvb commentedWould consider a temporary block appropriate. There is no excuse for such inappropriate behavior. It is ok to disagree, but feel there needs to be consequences for such behavior. Including the promise of permanent blocking when this kind of behavior is repeated anywhere.
Comment #5
avpadernoThe alternative to temporary blocking could be to temporary removing the confirmed role. If this is not a behavior the user repeated more than once, I would consider that an alternative.
Comment #6
gisleAFAIK, just being a webmaster, without the permission to administer users, there is no way to temporary block someone. I have access to a link that let me block someone. Once I do that, I lose all access to the user profile (403), and only someone with the "Administer users" permission can unblock the account.
Good idea. That can be reversed by a webmaster as soon as the user acknowledges the warning and promises to stop doing it.
Comment #7
mmjvb commentedThat would mean a webmaster needs to escalate to a user administrator. Consider the offence of foul language to a webmaster severe enough for a temporary block. Assuming you identified as webmaster of d.o.
No idea what to think about acknowledgement of the warning, would expect an apology for the foul language.
Comment #8
gisleNo, unfortunately I did not state explicitly that I was a d.o. webmaster. Maybe he wasn't aware that I could block him (for the record, I didn't block him, heeding the advice from volkswagenchick).
I shall remember to identify as d.o. webmaster the next time I send out a warning by means of a PM, but fortunately, there has been no incidents requiring a PM since this one.
Comment #9
mmjvb commentedThe foul language is not acceptable for anyone. Imagine me reporting his communication to the webmasters. I am just a user, no authority. Consider DCOC still applying.
Comment #10
avpadernoWebmasters can remove the confirmed role in the same way they can confirm users. I am a user administrator, but that is not a necessary role, in this case.
Name-calling users is not admissible whatever role the other user has. There isn't any justification in using such rude language, even if you didn't qualify as webmaster, user administrator, or administrator.
If you think it's necessary, I can send an email to that user, reminding him what behavior we expect.
Comment #11
gisleNo, this one has been sorted out (hence status "Fixed") . As already said: I acted upon the advice from volkswagenchick, reminding him about the DCOC and what behavior we expect. I have also received an apology, so there is nothing more to do here.