Give the gift of Drupal. All merchandise is 50% off through 2016.
From panels_edit_style_settings_form_validate in panels_renderer_editor class
My guess is that the display render is cached as init isn't being called for it either, so validation is being called but plugins file wasn't added, and bam fatal.
(very likely could be caused by something hackish I'm doing, but don't have the headspace to spend any more time on this atm.)