Give the gift of Drupal. All merchandise is 50% off through 2016.
The reminder watchdog entry is always inserted, even when the message has not actually been sent due to an error or a message alteration (see #800434: drupal_mail, allow hook_mail_alter implementation to cancel mail).
Testing the message result should be enough. Attached also a backported patch to 6.x.
The patch in #1 applies fine and fixes the issue.
Committed to D7, thanks!
Drupal is a registered trademark of Dries Buytaert.