Thanks for all the effort with Quickstart. I've enjoyed trying it on various things.

One question I have is clarifying how Quickstart is different from a usual Aegir install and why?

From what I can tell, and I'm no expert, it appears that a usual Aegir install allows for both multi-sites on a single codebase and multiple "platforms" or different codebases with the ability to clone sites from one platform to another.

Whereas, Quickstart creates websites each with their own codebase and downloads these fresh from the Drupal repository.

Am I missing something?
What are the reasons for doing this?
If this has already been answered please point me to it.

Thanks.

Comments

atuline’s picture

I would also be interested in more information on this and have been looking to setup a VM that includes git, Aegir and/or Quickstart, phpMyAdmin and a desktop. There is an Aegir VM at http://community.aegirproject.org/node/244, but I haven't been able to get phpMyAdmin running on it.

MichaelCole’s picture

Status: Active » Closed (fixed)

Hello, Quickstart and Aegir are different tools for different jobs.

I recommend you do your own research, install and work with both, and you'll understand them better.

Mike

izmeez’s picture

Status: Closed (fixed) » Needs work

@MichaelCole with respect to all the work you have and are doing on this project, I do not mean to suggest that you as the project maintainer needs to do the work of answering this support issue. But with respect I think it merits leaving open either for more information or for others to add their views. It is after all an open source community.

From my experience part of the challenge with Drupal is the need for a development platform of some sort sooner or later. There are various options vying for the attention of users. Quickstart is one option. XAMPP another. There are several other VM's including turnkeylinux.org drupal appliance as well as the Aegir VM mentioned in comment #1. And several recipes to create your own Drupal server that can be found by searching the Internet.

So what differences are people finding and can they share their thoughts to help each other and maybe increase awareness of the offerings and maybe even promote enhancements to them.

I'm sure we have all learned various things from our experiences and I think this might be a good place to do some comparative discussion. It sure beats using the forum where users cannot click on the most recent comment but have to scroll through to find new content, but I digress.

Can we please leave this issue thread open for discussion and comparison of Quickstart and other development environments, especially those so close that they are using the same modules (i.e. aegir, drush, make, provision) but configured differently?

Thank you

Izzy

MichaelCole’s picture

Hi Izzy,

Sure, let's leave it open. I hadn't considered that you were trying to start a general discussion. I try to keep the issue queue at 0 as a way to make sure I'm on top of things, but this is fine to leave open.

I'm more than open to this kind of discussion. If we get some information together, let's put it into a page in the handbook. There are lots of ways of doing things, and I don't think Quickstart is the only tool for them all.

Cheers,

Mike

izmeez’s picture

I have been exploring both environments and have a little bit better idea of the differences.

First, I think I was confused because I thought Quickstart was using Aegir but I don't think that is the case. As i looked deeper i see quickstart includes the script for installing aegir but this may be out of date depending on the version of quickstart and the changes in the aegir project.

Quickstart installs each website as a separate codebase and also includes a setup for virtual vhosts such that the website created is immediately available to through the local browser (Guest OS). With Aegir the user creates platforms and then multi-sites on each platform. Configuring virtual hosts is done manually from what I can see. I did not try installing aegir inside quickstart so I cannot speak to what happens then.

Yes, these are two different approaches. I can't provide any simple explanation of the use cases for each at this time - still learning.

MichaelCole’s picture

Component: Miscellaneous » Image Build
Status: Needs work » Closed (fixed)