Hi,
I'd like to try this module, but ran into a bunch of problems due to the lack of documentation and/or a README.txt.
E.g. it'd be nice to know before enabling it that this module conflicts with image module, if image.module uses the "image" content type (what it does by default).
Also it'd be nice to know if this module should run "out of the box" or if configuration steps are required. And it'd be evn nicer to know how it would be possible to modify the module, e.g. to use another content type name than "image", or if one could make it play nicely together with a views-enabled image.module.
Last but not least I'd love to know how this module differs from the solution discussed in Jeffs screencast.
Thanks & greetings, -asb
| Comment | File | Size | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| #8 | readme.txt | 4.13 KB | asb |
Comments
Comment #1
Anonymous (not verified) commentedIf a module depends/uses ImageField/ImageCache its usually safe to assume it is incompatible (unless otherwise stated) with Image.module I find.
Comment #2
asb commented> If a module depends/uses ImageField/ImageCache its usually safe to assume it is incompatible (unless otherwise stated)
> with Image.module I find.
Sorry, but I have to disagree. ImageField and Image.module *do* work fine on the same Drupal instgallation since ImageField by itself does not enforce a node type named "Image" - I've both running together on several sites. Also, ImageCache works very well together with Image.module. The incompatibility just applies to very limited use cases.
Greetings, -asb
Comment #3
Taxoman commentedAgreeing with you that these issues are relevant for practical documentation of this module.
Will look into this and see if I can come up with some improvements.
Comment #4
karens commentedThis module no longer defaults to 'image' for the image content type, which was the only problem using it with the image module. The other requirements are listed on the project page. This *is* the solution in Jeff's screencast, and there is no configuration to do, the module does it all.
If someone wants to add more documentation you can make a patch.
Comment #5
asb commentedI'm currently trying to transcribe Jeff's screencast at Howto: Node-based galleries with CCK and Views, I hope that's fine with Jeff and you?
However, there are still a couple of things in Jeff's screencast I can't reproduce yet so the "Howto" currently has an "Incomplete" flag set (e.g. I'm not getting the "Add photo" button).
> This module no longer defaults to 'image' for the image content type, which was the only problem using it with the image module.
Sorry, I can not reproduce this with the current release available, at least not in my D6 sandbox with running "image" module.
Trying to download and enable results in...:
> This *is* the solution in Jeff's screencast, and there is no configuration to do, the module does it all.
Sorry, I have to disagree again. At least the version I have running seems to use other content types (if I remember correctly - I'll have to re-check this). Also, I'm getting a "Broken/missing handler" in the "Fields" configuration of the view. Hm, maybe I should set up a fresh sandbox... Or maybe there's a fresher release in the works...?
Greetings, -asb
Edit: Note to others looking for the mentioned fixes: Karen has just checked this into CVS, so it's not yet available in a release.
Comment #6
karens commentedIf you use the latest version of the code in a fresh checkout things should work fine. You should not have to do anything, it will create the content types and views and an initial gallery node for you and configure everything else that needs to be done.
Since there's really nothing to do, I'm not sure what kind of help is needed. Again, if someone wants to tell me exactly what help seems to be missing I can add it.
Comment #7
asb commentedHi Karen,
thank you for the new release and sorry for nagging about documentation, but I would simply get some basic information to get started without having to read and understand the code. That's not out of lazyness, but simply because I don't speak PHP and do not understand the CCK database model. A short README.txt would suffice, then we coding analphabets could jump in and start to write handbook pages.
Basic information needed to get started:
Just to explain this: After installing and enabling 6.x-1.2 I'm seeing the following elements in my testing-new-modules sandbox:
(If "fresh checkout" in #6 referrs to a fresh Drupal installation: I haven't tried this yet since I'd like to use the module on existing sites. If the module requires a fresh Drupal installation, this would be a relevant requirement to be mentioned in a README.txt).
The only content type with an CCK imagefield is 'CCK Image', but I can't upload images into this field since it requires to select gallery, but there's no gallery available (and so on; I'm not troubleshooting here, simply describing what I'm seeing). So the basic information in a README.txt would be:
I need this to distinguish the 'views_gallery' content types and views from other/older content types and views created by other modules (which possibly have not been removed when uninstalling the module, or which are needed for other purposes, like an prallelly installed 'image' module). Also it'd be nice to know what would have to be done to customize the module; e.g.: If I change the settings at ./admin/settings/views_gallery, will this affect the (pre-) configureed view, or will the view be modified accordingly?
Upgrading and compatibility information needed:
More interestingly: Can I install the module on a site where Jeff's screencast has been implemented? Should I try this, or will there be conflicts? Can 'views_gallery' fully take over the existing Node-based galleries with CCK and Views?
Also, if there are known or to-be-expected conflicts with other content types (like those from 'image' module) or other modules, I'd like to know about them so I can try to resolve them.
This basic information would help to understand what the module is supposed to do and what might be a bug (ar an incompatibility, or an unrelated site-specific problem). And it hopefully would prevent feature requests like this one ;)
Thanks & greetings, -asb
(fixing version and attaching a quick draft for a README.txt, based on the project page)
Comment #8
asb commentedQuick draft for a README.txt (with missing parts to be added).
Comment #9
kakajoe commentedre #7 , nice...cause i really love this module, but somehow...its not work properly because i stuck with
Error: handler for node_data_field_gallery_image > field_gallery_image_fid doesn't exist!
i dont know where the mistake is...but seem like there not only me who has this error..
thank you for helping out...
ps : sorry for the bad english ... :P
Comment #10
karens commentedOK, added a README.txt using what you had.
As noted on the project page you cannot follow the screencast and manually create content types described there then install this module. You should install this module on a fresh site or remove the content types you created. The content type names had to be altered to avoid conflicts with the image module and numerous other fixes and features have been added.
Thanks for the text :)