Guardr Logo Redesign

The Guardr design team has worked on some logo concepts for review.

See attached.

Thank you C&T Manila Team for your contribution! We really appreciate it :)

I think they all look great. I really like the two minimal concepts. I could see it being mistaken for the Firefox logo without the pentagon badge behind it, though.

I like Concept 1: Execution 2: Simple with pentagon shape
I also like Concept 2: Execution 2: Bold and Graphic with pentagon shape

I feel like Concept 1: Execution 2 is the clear winner. It's clean, conveys strength and security, which is what Guardr is supposed to be about. While the Concept 2 options are visually compelling, they seem more cartoon-ish and feel a bit like they could just as easily be logos for video games. With that said, I'd totally play those games!

I agree with the comments above. My favorite is Concept 1, Execution 2. The Guardr name gets lost in most of Concept 2 options when viewing the logos at a smaller size.

I like Concept 1: Execution 2 is my first pick.
This logo also allows for the logo to be used without the "Guardr" text below it. This can be important when the logo is used in small sizes or as a favicon.

Concept 1: Execution 1 is my second pick.
Concept 2: Execution 2 is my third pick.

Concept 2: Execution 1 I dislike.
Concept 2: Execution 3 I dislike.

Thank you for considering my opinion.
Thank you to the folks providing their creative graphic design.

Thanks for all the input so far!

We had a Slack poll at Mediacurrent and will include that in the decision too.

1-01 - 4 votes
1-02 - 3 votes
2-01 - 0 votes
2-02 - 5 votes
2-03 - 0 votes

It isn't all about votes, but this all helps a lot! Looking to make the decision by 10/31 if possible. Still time to weigh-in.

I would like to make a call on the logo selection for Guardr at our Tuesday scrum 2019-11-05 4:30pm ET. Feel free to join to discuss or add additional comments here.

The concepts below are the top three logo concepts based on Slack poll votes and Drupal community comments in this issue:

1-01 (7 votes, 8 if you count it as a second choice for a user)
02-02 (5 votes, 6 if you count it as a second choice for a user)
1-02 (4 votes, all were comments in this issue)

Big thank to everyone who weighed-in on the logo design! The community has selected Concept 1: Execution 1!

I really want to thank @shereehill and the Code and Theory Manila design team for the designs. Our next step will be to ask for delivery of the logo with various versions and formats we need.