Drupal 7 port of Comment OG?

If there's a demand for it, then yes. Anyone else think there's a need for this in D7?

+1

The stuff that this module does needs to get into og core, IMHO.
So +1.

I talked to Moshe about this a few years ago. Either way, I'm glad other people seem to think so! I'll work on an upgrade this week.

+

Perhaps another eventual route of solving the comment permissions problem would be to look at #10426: Make comment permission more granular.?

+1

+1

Yes!

add me. I can do testing and basic drupal dev if you want help.

A new dev branch has been opened up that contains an alpha release. The 7 version takes advantage of the new granular permission system with OG. I'm going to add edit and delete functionality soon, but for now at least comments can be turned off for non-members or for members only of a certain role. Test in good health.

getting this error when trying to go to comment settings.
"Fatal error: Call to undefined function comment_og_admin_edit_msg() in C:\xampp\htdocs\faasn\sites\all\modules\comment_og\comment_og.module on line 31"

Good catch. Apparently I kept a lot of extra stuff in the module for features that don't exist at this point (the settings page is unnecessary). If you grab the latest dev it should work fine, but here's a quick patch of the changes for reference.

I just added updated the dev branch with edit, approve, and delete functionality. Testing seems good at this point. I'm going to test a little bit more on my end and then tag this as a beta release. After that point, I'll consider this issue closed.

Beta now available!