Lots of differences between D7 and D8 and no where near same level of capability.

A feature set/roadmap for Rules D8 might help to generate interest and communicate ideas.

Rules is a very important part of Drupal. Will rules D8 catch up and improve on D7? Whats ahead?

Thanks

Comments

laurencefass created an issue. See original summary.

tr’s picture

Project: Rules Essentials » Rules
Version: 8.x-1.x-dev » 8.x-3.x-dev

Lots of differences between D7 and D8 and no where near same level of capability.

I disagree - Rules in D8 is just as capable, in some ways more than D7. But the UI is currently inadequate to allow you to make use of these capabilities.

A feature set/roadmap for Rules D8 might help to generate interest and communicate ideas.

Rules is a very important part of Drupal. Will rules D8 catch up and improve on D7? Whats ahead?

These things are already discussed in the Rules issue queue and in the contrib_tracker queue and on the d8rules.org web site. IMO it doesn't need more discussion, Rules needs people to help out in the issue queue - answer support questions, review patches, contribute patches, help port contributed modules, provide examples, write documentation, and yes even monetary support so that the volunteer maintainers can afford to devote more time to these tasks.

tr’s picture

Status: Active » Fixed
Syntapse’s picture

Status: Fixed » Active
Syntapse’s picture

Thanks for replying. I hope this reply doesn't come across in anyway as antagonistic but I would like to be a bit critical of the documentation. Having a clear idea of what's ahead for D8 Rules will help me (and I'm sure others) push it to clients and generate potential dev funding sources.

I'm not seeking more discussion but I don't think the issue queue is the best place for users of the Rules module to be hunting for features and roadmaps. A lot of people will be familiar with D7 Rules (myself included) and I quickly lost momentum with D8 rules - finding lots of undocumented missing parts especially the scheduled actions.

ref to: https://d8rules.org/ What milestones/features are completed? The latest news is from 2017. What's missing from D8 present in D7? How will D8 surpass D7 in terms of functionality? Documents are not clear and I have no time to test by trial and error. It would be great to know what is working now, and what is in the immediate pipeline ready for testing. I have two clients asking for scheduled events but I can't offer that right now and (surprisingly) Drupal doesn't offer scheduled events natively.

If the we (I?) had a better idea of a timescales and a clear feature list we might be able to sell features to clients and generate fundingfor further development. That's difficult given the present docs and (my) lack of clarity comparing with D7 features.

Thanks

tr’s picture

Status: Active » Fixed

I would like to be a bit critical of the documentation

And the way to fix that is to participate. I am doing my part. Much more than my part, with all the stuff I've been writing in https://www.drupal.org/docs/8/modules/d8-rules-essentials and the literally hundreds of examples I've been providing in answer to support questions over the past year. I've fixed over 350 bugs in Rules and answered more than 1100 issues over the past year. And I've become co-maintainer for many modules that use Rules, in order to help them as well. Look at my drupal.org profile - lots and lots of contributions from me ... In short I am not sympathetic to anyone saying that I need to do more. Ask some of the other 300,000 Rules users to help.

I can't do everything myself. All the information is out there, and it requires the community to step up and put it into more useful form when necessary. All the drupal.org documentation can be edited and added to by anyone, so if there's something confusing or missing then figure it out and correct or improve the documentation. With 300,000 users, I'm sure there is at least one other person who understands enough to help out with the documentation. But no one is doing that, just being critical.

I have no time to test by trial and error. It would be great to know what is working now, and what is in the immediate pipeline ready for testing. I have two clients asking for scheduled events but I can't offer that right now and (surprisingly) Drupal doesn't offer scheduled events natively.

OK, let's turn that around - your assumption is that I do have time? I'm 100% volunteer here. I do not get paid by anyone for this. Your example is the Rules Scheduler - Even though anyone in the community could have ported this at any time over the past 5 years, I am the one who recently voluntarily started (and almost finished) the port on my own time with no help. I am also the one who has answered dozens of questions in the issue queue about the scheduler. I will finish that port when it rises to the top of my priority list again, or someone else can come along and finish it if they need it. But you are the one who would get paid to use the results of all my porting work. Why is it on me to provide you with free work and free support? Isn't this a community project, and aren't you part of the community? What is your contribution here?

If Rules is important to you, help out in some way. Hire me to finish Rules Scheduler for D8, if it's important to you. Contribute to the documentation with what you currently know. Port the D7 documentation to D8. Provide examples. Read the issue queue for useful information and put that into the documentation. Test and review the 57 "Needs review" patches currently in the issue queue. Write test cases. Help with the issues tagged "beta blocker", or "Novice", or "Contributor". Help with porting any Rules contributed modules that you use/need - for example Flag, Mime Mail, HTML Mail, etc. Participate in (or organize!) a sprint or a local Drupal user's group. Answer any support questions you can in the Rules issue queue. Everything you do means one less thing I need to do myself, which means D8 Rules will have a stable release that much sooner.

Specifically, contribute SOME of your time to the project, in return for the benefit you're receiving from this open-source project provided to you for free.

I don't mean to sound antagonistic either, but this is not a commercial product. Before I started as maintainer last year, bugs/feature requests/support requests were going unanswered for years. Sometime for 5, 6, or even 7 years! I have changed that and made tremendous progress towards completing D8 Rules, but again without community participation (this means you) this is unsustainable.

Short answer:

  • Feature list - everything that was in D7 Rules as a minimum.
  • Time scale - depends on how much support I get. Right now it's just me, and as a volunteer doing this in my spare time I'm not going to commit to any time scale. Getting two helpers out of the current 300,000 users would make this go three times as fast. A dozen helpers and this could be finished by the end of the month.

I am marking this "Fixed" because I feel I've answered this support question and that there's nothing more to be added. And I don't want to discuss it any more - be part of the solution or be part of the problem. There are many open documentation issues in the queue - we only need one that says "more documentation", and we need people to provide the specific documentation that is asked for in the other issues.

Status: Fixed » Closed (fixed)

Automatically closed - issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.