Views after nodes in URL [#1492656]

Hi,

I have this configuration:

A simple node page with path "shop" (show normal text as overview)
A simple "child" node page with path "shop/term-conditions" (show normal text)
A Views page with path "shop/used-accessories" (show a list of nodes, no arguments, no %, nothing complicated: a very simple view page)

A simple hierarchical menu that links all the above:

MyMenu:
--shop
----Term and conditions
----Used accessories

With sub-pathauto DISABLED:

I obtain the correct behaviour, such as:

Clicking on "shop" menu item, the relative "shop" node is correctly shown
Clicking on "Term and conditions" menu item, the relative "term-conditions" node is correctly shown
Clicking on "Used accessories" menu item, the relative "used-accessories" view page is correctly shown

With sub-pathauto ENABLED:

I obtain a wrong behaviour, such as:

Clicking on "shop" menu item, the relative "shop" node is correctly shown
Clicking on "Term and conditions" menu item, the relative "term-conditions" node is correctly shown
Clicking on "Used accessories" menu item, the relative "used-accessories" view page IS NOT SHOWN and the node "shop" is shown instead.

This bug is also triggered even if I increment the "Maximum depth of sub-paths to alias" value in sub-pathauto settings.

What's wrong?

Thank you very much

Comments

Comment #0.0

MXT

Italian

Milan

CreditAttribution: MXT commented 21 March 2012 at 15:51

Issue summary:

View changes

Minor typo

Comment #1

jaymcgraw CreditAttribution: jaymcgraw commented 21 March 2012 at 20:38

Witnessing this same behavior with sub-pathauto when page (and therefore path) is defined by a view.

Comment #1.0

jaymcgraw CreditAttribution: jaymcgraw commented 21 March 2012 at 20:38

Issue summary:

View changes

Sorry, another minor typo

Comment #2

MXT

Italian

Milan

CreditAttribution: MXT commented 1 April 2012 at 21:22

If I change the views path from "shop/used-accessories" to "node/37/used-accessories" all works fine.

(37 is the nid of my node with "shop" alias)

So, using sub-pathauto module we have to use system path with hard coded NIDS (e.g. node/37) in all views paths? Even if it's not necessary? (In my case I don't need % in my views path)

Thank you for some explanation.

Comment #3

MXT

Italian

Milan

CreditAttribution: MXT commented 1 April 2012 at 21:38

And also I have to add the system path in the "Show block on specific pages" blocks setting to correctly trigger a block visibility on the above pages, like this:

Show block on specific pages
...
* Only the listed pages:
shop
shop/*
node/37/*

Things now work in this way, but I think this is not a correct behaviour (think the complications for node translations for esample, where I have different NIDS in different languages for the same pages!), so I mark this as 'major' bug

Thank you very much

Comment #4

MXT

Italian

Milan

CreditAttribution: MXT commented 1 April 2012 at 21:39

Priority:

Normal

» Major

Comment #5

BWPanda CreditAttribution: BWPanda commented 27 April 2012 at 07:51

Title:	Strange behaviour	» Views after nodes in URL
Version:	7.x-1.2	» 7.x-1.x-dev

I too came across this behaviour:

I have an 'About' page node at www.example.com/about. I want to display a view so the URL is www.example.com/about/my-view, however this doesn't work (same as original post above) and I have to instead use www.example.com/node/1/my-view...

The URL then displays correctly as www.example.com/about/my-view, however hard-coding node IDs in the URL is not ideal. A solution that allows us to use regular (aliased) paths in Views would be good.