I'm using nodecomments module for comments on a bilingual (French/English) page. The page is translated but the comments are not. I'd like to display all the comments from both languages on both the French and English pages.

Using views 2 and i18nviews I can achieve this for the original page whether French or English (default) but I can't get the translated page to display any of the comments.

View uses:
Relationship - Node comment: Original Parent Nid or Self
Argument - (Node) Node translation: Translation set node ID

This seems to work in only one direction and displays comments from the translation on the original.

Any suggestions about how to get it to work from the original to the translation?

Comments

janadam’s picture

I'm also interested in this.

miro_dietiker’s picture

Status: Active » Postponed (maintainer needs more info)

Have you tried applying the argument on the right relationship?

Have you also tried adding a second parent tnid relationship and filter the argument on the new tnid node relationship?

I think one of those two should succeed your needs.