Mass crediting on an issue

Things properly broke when the issue got to about 1061 comments because d.o unpublished the issue and won't re-publish until a few comments had been deleted.

:O :O :O :O :O

So for now I would suggest:

1. Bulk-delete the credit comments which unfortunately means those people are not explicitly credited yet, but better than a halfway state where the issue is broken.
2. Programmatically unfollow everyone.
3. Credit just Gábor Hojtsy.
4. Commit with a full message including everyone. (This was what I had planned to do for this issue, without explicit issue credit.)
5. Comment with a note/apology on the issue once everyone is unfollowed and the issue is updated as to what was tried and failed.
6. Follow up to add credit for them at a later time if desired since in my limited knowledge the credit system might have to be completely reimplemented to support this safely.

Deleting the comment that credits the user also removes the credit - I guess this is just a feature of the issue credit system since you need a comment for credit.

Credit is stored as entity references to comments by credited people. Any organizations referenced are on those comments, so it let’s people update that by editing their comment. When you credit someone, the underlying implementation is actually to post a comment as the credited person.

To credit everyone, I’d do it like you did, but in separate issue batches of 900 or less. After improvements from this issue. And maybe programmatically rather than via the UI.

I think this rises beyond the permissions of webmasters.

Unsubscribe everyone who is subscribed to #2850540: Remove multilingual initiative from MAINTAINERS.txt as completed because of my crediting.

Done.

(apparently) Users are sent an email from me using my email address informing that they are credited. I think this should use the system email and not disclose mine.

The header on my credit email from this is: From: "alexpott (Drupal.org)" <noreply@drupal.org>

I can’t spot your email anywhere in the message.

Things properly broke when the issue got to about 1061 comments because d.o unpublished the issue and won't re-publish until a few comments had been deleted.

We haven’t verified this in the logs, but it sounds like Suhosin. Suhosin strips POST data which is out of its limits, and the published checkbox is at the end of POST data.

Everybody who is credited on the issue is also subscribed to the issue - this is wrong we shouldn't be automatically subscribing people to issues when they are credited.

My thinking there was the usual case for crediting someone who hasn’t commented is that they helped out in a discussion, and I would think their ongoing input would be relevant and useful. And since these are comments posted as the person being credited, that all happened by default, so the implementation was easy.

I think that’s a debate for a separate issue. I don’t have any information on whether people being credited expect to follow the issue or not; or if they like or don’t like being auto-followed.

I recommend posting a second issue to credit the remaining ~600 people in the same way, and I’ll unfollow them shortly after.

#12 and any other followups shouldn’t need to block that.

RE #12 and the discussion about auto-following... This one issue was kind of a special case, due to the huge number of people being credited. I was one of the people who started getting lots of emails about the issue, due to the auto-following, and I can tell you that I didn't appreciate it very much. Also, when I went to the issue page to try to un-follow the issue, some JavaScript on the page (possibly dreditor?) made it load very very slowly, so unfollowing it was difficult.

That said, in the more normal case of "I know this person worked on this issue because it was spun off of something else but they haven't commented here yet", I don't think that having the person being credited automatically Follow the issue is a completely terrible thing... But then again, for those of us who have hundreds (if not more) issues that they follow, getting another Follow added by someone else is not a great thing either.

So I think I'm falling in with the "Credit != follow" crowd. If I get a "you've been credited" message, I can click on the link and follow the issue if I want to keep getting notified about it.

I guess you wanted this discussion on a separate issue, but this one only has 5 followers so far, and there isn't another one yet... so.

Also +1 to the suggestion in #6. Delete all the current credit comments on the main issue, then make child issues to credit people, each with fewer comments (600 was suggested, so you'd need 3 child issues). That will (a) make sure each person is "credited with fixing a Drupal Core issue" (for profile/marketplace ranking counts) and (b) not overwhelm the system. And maybe those credit comments can be added programmatically without causing a "follow" for this one case.

#2853669: Crediting someone in an issue should not cause them to follow the issue is the followup for the following behavior.

I recommend leaving #2850540: Remove multilingual initiative from MAINTAINERS.txt as completed as-is.

I’ll make a script which mass-adds credit to a fresh separate issue. The plan is to have it send the “[@project] You’ve been credited in @title!” email to everyone, but not follow the issue. There will be a small number of people that get double-notified, the ones who got caught in the deleting-until-the-issue-worked. We don’t need to make that number higher.

In case this comes up again, the script I'm using is

$uids = [
…
];
$nid = 2853680;

foreach (user_load_multiple($uids) as $account) {
  // Save initial issue comment.
  $node = node_load($nid, NULL, TRUE);
  $node->nodechanges_comment['comment_body'][LANGUAGE_NONE][0] = [
    'value' => t('!maintainer credited !name.', [
      '!maintainer' => theme('username', ['account' => $GLOBALS['user']]),
      '!name' => theme('username', ['account' => $account]),
    ]),
    'format' => filter_default_format(),
  ];
  $node->nodechanges_comment_attributes = [
    'project_issue_no_email' => TRUE,
    'skip_flag_tracker' => TRUE,
  ];
  $node->nodechanges_uid = $account->uid;
  // Copy attribution from the user’s last comment.
  if ($cid = db_query_range('SELECT cid FROM {comment} c INNER JOIN {node} n ON n.nid = c.nid AND n.type IN (:issue_types) AND n.status = :node_published WHERE c.status = :comment_published AND c.uid = :uid AND c.created > 1426194356 ORDER BY c.cid DESC', 0, 1, array(':issue_types' => project_issue_issue_node_types(), ':node_published' => NODE_PUBLISHED, ':comment_published' => COMMENT_PUBLISHED, ':uid' => $account->uid))->fetchField()) {
    $last_comment = comment_load($cid);
    $node->nodechanges_comment['field_attribute_as_volunteer'] = $last_comment->field_attribute_as_volunteer;
    $node->nodechanges_comment['field_attribute_contribution_to'] = $last_comment->field_attribute_contribution_to;
    $node->nodechanges_comment['field_for_customer'] = $last_comment->field_for_customer;
  }
  node_save($node);

  // Notify the creditee. See _project_issue_email_notify().
  $from = '"' . mime_header_encode(t('!name (!site)', array('!name' => $GLOBALS['user']->name, '!site' => variable_get('site_name', 'Drupal')))) . '" <' . variable_get('project_issue_reply_to_' . $node->type, variable_get('site_mail', ini_get('sendmail_from'))) . '>';
  drupal_mail('drupalorg', 'credited_by_maintainer', $account->mail, LANGUAGE_NONE, ['node' => $node], $from);
}

executed with --user=157725

The second batch of credit is at #2853680: Remove multilingual initiative from MAINTAINERS.txt as completed. I think this is all handled.

So it looks like anyone who actually commented as a real human on #2850540: Remove multilingual initiative from MAINTAINERS.txt as completed was not credited nor included in the commit message, including me, penyaskito, and vijaycs85 at least. We are unchecked on #2850540: Remove multilingual initiative from MAINTAINERS.txt as completed and not added on #2853680: Remove multilingual initiative from MAINTAINERS.txt as completed, and not listed in the commit message.

So regarding #22, @alexpott has re-checked those who were missed.

To fix the commit message, we agreed this might be the best course:

1. git revert 8c01266a8c
   and
   git revert a6ed0958
   but do not use the ~KB-long default message; instead:
   Revert "Issue #2850540": fixing issue credit
2. Recommit using a commit message based on the canonical, alphabetized list in the summary:
   

   git commit -m 'Issue #2850540 by Gábor Hojtsy, -enzo-, 1ethylotest, 5ven, 12345678912345678, @baux, a.milkovsky, a.ross, a1russell, aaronaverill, aaronott, ACF, achton, acrollet, adam7, Adam Clarey, adci_contributor, Adita, AdrianB, afeijo, agentrickard, agoradesign, agrozyme, aimeerae, ainigma32, aitiba, ajeverson, AjitS, akahn, akalata, akejoha, akoe, akozma, aks22, AkshayKalose, Alan D., Alan Evans, alansaviolobo, alarcombe, alberto56, Albert Volkman, alduya, alerque, alexanderpas, Alex Bukach, alexh58, alexkb, alexpott, Alex UA, alexweber, alex_b, Alice Heaton, alimac, alippai, almaudoh, aloyr, altavis, Alumei, alvar0hurtad0, alweb, amateescu, ameenkhan07, ameymudras, amitaibu, amitgoyal, amontero, amourow, anarcat, anavarre, ancamp, andrei.dincu, andrejsmuzikovs, andremolnar, andyceo, andymartha, andypost, andythomnz, aneek, anemes, aniket_m, anil280988, anish.a, ankitgarg, annikaC, anrikun, Antonnavi, Antti J. Salminen, Anushka-mp, Anybody, ardas, areke, arianek, aries, arkestra, Arla, arlinsandbulte, Arnoldski, Aron Novak, aroq, arpitr, ars-, arshadcn, arskiainen, artem.ua, Artusamak, arunaseva, asb, aschiwi, Ashish.Dalvi, AshishK-dupe, ashutoshsngh, ashwinikumar, askibinski, aspilicious, astra, attiks, attila.fekete, aturetta, August1914, Aunion, avillager, axe312, axel.rutz, axooh, ayelet_Cr, azinck, a_thakur, a_webb, b0unty, babasse05, babruix, badrange, Bairnsfather, balagan, balintcsaba, balintk, BalrajB, bannorb, banviktor, BarisW, barraponto, basic, basvanderveen, batigolix, bbinkovitz, bboty, Bcwald, bechtold, beejeebus, bendev, benelori, Benia, benjf, benjifisher, benjy, BenK, bensemmel, Berdir, beretta627, BeyersdorferTJ, bforchhammer, bfroehle, bgm, bighappyface, bill richardson, bird-cage, biro.botond, bisonbleu, bjaspan, blackdog, BlacKICEUA, blazey, bleen, blueminds, blue_waters, BMDan, bobrov1989, Bodo Maass, bojanz, Bojhan, Bojhan.core, bonus, Boobaa, bookmarvel, boran, borisbaldinger, borisson_, botanic_spark, botris, bowersox, boztek, brandon.holtsclaw, brantwynn, brianV, BrightBold, BrockBoland, bryancasler, bryanmanalo, bserem, bshaffer, bsherwood, bsztreha, bucefal91, Buratino42, bwinett, Bès, c-c-m, c4doug, c31ck, c960657, CaDyMaN, caktux, CalebD, calebtr, calliandra, Cameron Tod, camoa, Caralin, Carl Johan, carsonevans, Carsten Müller, carwin, casey, catch, cbiggins, cburschka, ceardach, cebasqueira, cedric_a, cesarmiquel, cha0s, chakrapani, ChandeepKhosa, Charles Belov, charmi, cheops90, Chi, chipway, chishah92, chr.fritsch, chrisbloomfield, chrischinchilla, Chris Dart, chrishks, chrisjlee, Chris Luckhardt, chrispomeroy, ChristianAdamski, Christopher James Francis Rodgers, chx, cilefen, ciprian.stavovei, ckaotik, CKoch, clashar, claudinec, Claudis, claudiu.cristea, clemens.tolboom, CMS Dude, codemonkie, Codenator, codexmas, Cogax, colan, colbol, cordoval, Corregidor, corvus_ch, cosmicdreams, Cottser, Countzero, cpelham, cpj, craychee, Crell, criscom, crispiatico, crotown, crowdcg, csakiistvan, csc4, csg, cshuangtw, cspitzlay, cs_shadow, cweagans, cwells, cwgordon7, Cyberschorsch, Cyberwolf, Cyclodex, czigor, czoper, c_archer, C_Logemann, D4K0, dado, daffie, dagmar, dagmita, dags, damiankloip, DamienMcKenna, Damien Tournoud, dan2k3k4, danielnolde, Daniel_Rempe, Daniel_Rose, danigrrl, danillonunes, DanPir, danquah, danylevskyi, das-peter, dasjo, dasrecht, daulet2030, Dave.Ingram, Dave Cohen, Dave Reid, david.lukac, davidhernandez, David Hernández, David Latapie, David Lesieur, David Stosik, David Strauss, david_garcia, David_Rothstein, dawehner, dbjpanda, dboulet, dcam, dclavain, dcmistry, dcmouyard, dcrocks, dddave, ddrozdik, Deciphered, deepakaryan1988, delmarr, Denchev, DeNelo, denis_kv, denjell, denutkarsh, derek.deraps, derEremit, dergachev, dermario, desbeers, desiboli, develCuy, deveshpal, Devin Carlson, devuo, Dhorkiy, DickJohnson, Didier Misson, diego21, digitaldonkey, dileepmaurya, dimaro, dinarcon, disasm, dishabhadra, divined, dixon_, djdevin, DjebbZ, djevans, dlu, dman, Dmitriy.trt, dobrzyns, docker, dodorama, dokumori, Dom., donquixote, dorficus, douggreen, dpacassi, dpearcefl, dpi, dpopdan, Dragan Eror, drewish, Dries, drifter, dropcube, dropfen, droplet, drubage, drugan, drumm, drunken monkey, Drupa1ish, drupalninja99, drupleg, druprad, dschenk, dsnopek, D Szkiba, dtarc, DuaelFr, dubcanada, dubois, dudycz, duellj, durifal, Dustin@PI, dutchyoda, DuttonMa, dvinegla, dww, dysrama, Désiré, e0ipso, e2thex, earnie, eaton, ebeyrent, ebrowet, Ec1ipsis, ecedenyo, echoz, EclipseGc, ecvandenberg, edgewl2, EdizonTN, edmoran, edrupal, edurenye, edutrul, edward_or, effulgentsia, eftimitac, egouleau, ehegedus, eigentor, eiriksm, ekes, el7cosmos, elachlan, elcuco, eleisoncruz, elfur, Eli-T, Elijah Lynn, eliza411, emanuelrighetto, emarchak, emma.maria, emmene-moi, eojthebrave, epari.siva, epoitras, er.manojsharma, er.pushpinderrana, ericdsd, ericduran, ericski, Eric_A, ErikWegner, ErnoVanhala, ershov.andrey, esbenvb, esclapes, eshta, esolitos, estoyausente, eugenesia, eule, EvanDonovan, Everett Zufelt, evilehk, Eyal Shalev, ezeedub, ezra-g, Fabianx, fabpot, fabsor, facine, fago, fakingfantastic, falcon03, faline, Fannon, fastangel, fenda, fgm, Fidelix, fietserwin, filijonka, FiNeX, fjd, Fleshgrinder, floretan, FMB, fmizzell, foopang, foxtrotcharlie, FrancescoQ, Frando, Frank Ralf, fran seva, franskuipers, franz, FredCK, FrenchBarbu, Freso, frob, frodeste, fubhy, fureigh, fwalch, g089h515r806, g3r4, Gabr1el, gabriel.achille, Gabriel R., Gaelan, gaele, gagarine, gapple, garphy, Garrett Albright, gaspaio, gaurav.goyal, gaurav26570, gauravjeet, gauravkhambhala, gausarts, gbentley, gdevashi, geerlingguy, geertvd, generalredneck, genjohnson, geoffreyr, george.echim, Georgii, GerdC, Gerhard Killesreiter, giancarlosotelo, giorgio79, GiorgosK, gloob, gngn, gnindl, gnuget, gobilo, gobinathm, golddragon007, good_man, googletorp, goudal, gpapadongonas, grahl, Grayside, greenc, greenSkin, greg.1.anderson, Greg Boggs, greggles, Greg Sims, grisendo, grubshka_v2, guillaumev, gumanist, guygg, guy_schneerson, gvso, gyuhyon, h3rj4n, Hadi Farnoud, hairqles, hampercm, Hanno, hansfn, hargobind, haripalrao, harrrrrrr, hass, hatcat, hauruck, Haza, hbblogger, hchonov, heather, heddn, hefox, Heihachi88, Heine, hejazee, helenkim, hellolindsay, henribergius, herom, herved, heykarthikwithu, heyrocker, hgoto, hguo, hinikato, hitesh-jain, hitfactory, hkirsman, HnLn, HOG, holist, holly.ross.drupal, holtzermann17, hook_awesome, hostedpower, hpz, hron84, hswong3i, hudo, Hummer, huss, hussainweb, Hydra, iamEAP, iampuma, ianthomas_uk, ibullock, IceCreamYou2, icseh., id.medion, idebr, idflood, ifrik, ifux, igasi, iliphil, imadalin, iMiksu, imkartik, indytechcook, InternetDevels, intuited, inwebsolutions, IshaDakota, isholgueras, Ismail Cherri, isntall, iszabi, itarato, ivanchaer, ivanjaros, Ivan Zugec, izmeez, izus, J-Lee, j.somers, j0rd, j2r, Jacine, jackhutton, JacobSanford, jagalbraith, jaimeguzman, jair, jakow, Jalandhar, jamesharv, jamesliu78, jamiehollern, jamiezeidler, jan.stoeckler, janoka, janusman, japerry, japicoder, jaredsmith, jasonyarrington, javisr, jaxxed, jayboodhun, JayMN, Jaypan, Jaza, jbrown, jcisio, jcnventura, jcost, jdanthinne, jeanfei, Jeff Burnz, Jeffrey C., jefkin, Jelle_S, jeni_dc, jenlampton, jepSter, jerdavis, jerdnas, Jeroen, jeroenbegyn, JeroenT, Jerome F, jespermb, jessebeach, jessehs, jgrubb, jgSnell, jhedstrom, jherencia, jhodgdon, jibran, jimmyX, jimyhuang, JirkaRybka, jiv_e, jjcarrion, jlbellido, jlscott, jmauro8ac, jmesam, jmikii, jmmarquez, jmolivas, jnicola, joachim, joates, Jody Lynn, joelpittet, joewatkins, Jo Fitzgerald, joginderpc, johanv, JohnAlbin, John Bickar, John Cook, johnheaven, johnish@gmail.com, johnv, John_B, jojonmaster, jomarocas, Jon@s, jonasdk, jonhattan, JonMcL, Jon Pugh, jordanpagewhite, joris.verschueren, josedanielestrada, joseph.olstad, josephdpurcell, josepvalls, Jose Reyero, joshi.rohit100, joshmccormack, joshtaylor, joshua.boltz, JoshuaRogers, joyceg, jpd4nt, jproctor, jrglasgow, jrockowitz, jsbalsera, jstoller, jthorson, juampynr, juancasantito, Juan Duarte, juankvillegas, juanramonperez, juanse254, juhovh, Julfabre, JuliaBayer, JuliaKM, julien, JulienD, junedkazi, justAChris, JvE, jvieille, jvns, jweowu, jwilson3, k4, k4v, kalabro, kalman.hosszu, kardave, karengrey, KarenS, karmazzin, Karmen, Kartagis, katbailey, kate_kalashnikova, kathyh, kattekrab, Kazanir, kbasarab, kbentham, KCarlile, kcouch, keith.smith, kekkis, kenorb, keopx, kerby70, kerrymick, kevee, Kevin Morse, KevinVb, keyral, kfritsche, kgoel, kholloway, kiamlaluno, kid_icarus, Kifah Meeran, kika, kikoalonsob, kiliweb, killerpoke, killes@www.drop.org, killua99, kim.pepper, Kiphaas7, kiwad, KJankko, klausi, klonos, kmharrell, knalstaaf, kompressaur, Konstantin Komelin, kopeboy, koppie, kostyashupenko, KRaisor, kreatIL, kriboogh, KrisBulman, Kristen Pol, kristiaanvandeneynde, kristink2, krlucas, kscheirer, ksenzee, kunal.kursija, kurt.iverson, l0ke, lachezar.valchev, lahoosascoots, lambic, langworthy, lanthaler, LaravZ, larowlan, LarsKramer, larsmw, Lars Toomre, LAsan, laszlo.kovacs, lathan, LatinBoy, lauriii, lavira, laxman.ghavte, lazysoundsystem, lba_emanuel, LeeHunter, leenwebb, leeotzu, Leeteq, legaudinier, legolasbo, Leksat, Lendude, leofishman, leonrenkema, leschekfm, Les Lim, Letharion, LewisNyman, lhangea, Liam McDermott, Liam Morland, likin, lilou, linclark, LinL, liquidcms, lisarex, LittleViking, litwol, lixiphp, ljcarnieri, lluvigne, lmeurs, loganfsmyth, lokapujya, lomasr, LoMo, lonelyrobot, longwave, lostkangaroo, lotyrin, LoveCharge, lpalgarvio, lslinnet, lsmith77, ltrane, lucascaro, lucaschain, lucastockmann, lucian.cazaciuc, luismagr, Lukas von Blarer, lund.mikkel, Luxian, lvbeck, lydie, m.c.t, m1r1k, maartendeblock, maciej.zgadzaj, MacMladen, Mac_Weber, maggo, magico, magnjorg, maijs, Malerio, mallezie, Manjit.Singh, manningpete, manoloka, MantasK, manu4543, manuel.afonso, Manuel Garcia, Maouna, Marc Angles, marcel66, Marc Hannaford, marcingy, marco, marcoscano, marcus7777, marcushenningsen, marcusx, marcvangend, marfillaster, mariancalinro, Mariano, mario.awad, mark., mark.labrecque, markcarver, markdorison, markie, MarkusDBX, markus_petrux, Mark_L6n, marthinal, martin107, Martin Mayer, martin_klima, martin_q, marvil07, marvin_B8, maryedith, mas0h, mashermike, masipila, matason, MathieuSpil, Mathijs Koenraadt, Matroschker, matsbla, matt2000, MattDanger, Matt V., mattyoung, Matze202, Maune, mauzeh, mavimo, maxchock, maxocub, maxterner23, maxtorete, mbaynton, mbovan, mbrett5062, mbyrnes, mcarbone, mcdruid, mcrittenden, mdespeuilles, mdrummond, mducharme, mdupont, me-sasha, meanderix, mecano, MegaChriz, memoo, merlinofchaos, mesr01, Metal3d, meyertox, mfb, mgifford, mglaman, mgriego, mhagedon, MHLut, MichaelCole, michaelfavia, michaellenahan, michaelmol, MichaelP, Michelle, michlis, micnap, mics.programming, Mihai-Alin, mikeker, mikemiles86, mikeryan, mikewink, mikey_p, mikispeed, mikl, Mile23, milopca, minff, mioan, Mirabuck, mirocow, mirom, miro_dietiker, mirsoft, mitchell, mitokens, mitron, mitrpaka, mitsuroseba, Mixologic, mjohnq3, mjreich, mkalkbrenner, mkapst, mkernel, mlecha, mlehner616, mlewand, mlncn, mmatsoo, mmilano, moe4715, mogio_hh, mohsen81666, Mojtaba Reyhani, mondrake, mon_franco, mooffie, morenstrat, mortendk, moshe weitzman, mparker17, mpdonadio, mpg, mpp, mr.baileys, mr.york, mradcliffe, mrded, mrf, MrHaroldA, mrjmd, mrP, mrsinguyen, msonnabaum, mstrelan, mtift, mtomaizy, mustafau, MustangGB, mvc, my-family, myforgedoteu, myLies, myram, mzwyssig, n3or, nadavoid, nagwani, NancyDru, nateszytel, natuk, naught101, naveenvalecha, naveko, NaX, naxoc, nbz, ndewhurst, ndobromirov, ndvo, neclimdul, nedjo, neetu morwani, nerdstein, nesta_, netbjarne, netkaiser, nevergone, nevets, ngocketit, nicholosophy, nick_schuch, Nick_vh, nicrodgers, nicu, nicxvan, nikhilasrani, nikhilsukul, nikkubhai, Niklas Fiekas, niko-, NITEMAN, Nitesh Sethia, nkschaefer, nlisgo, NobodyLikesGreg, nod_, Noe_, Nomes, NonProfit, nonsie, noomz, NotNotCow, no_angel, no_commit_credit, no_longer_active_13, nsputnik, nvinayvinay, nyirocsaba, nyleve101, oadaeh, oheller, Olafski, olegiv, Oleksiy, olli, omar, omercioglu, omers, OnkelTem, opi, oresh, oriol_e9g, orlitzky, othermachines, oussema, Outi, Owen Barton, pameeela, Pancho, Paracetamol, paranojik, parasite, paresha.uchdadiya, ParisLiakos, parthipanramesh, pashupathi nath gajawada, Pasqualle, patrickd, Patrick Storey, paularmand, Paul Broon, paulmckibben, pbattino, pbland, pbonnefoi, pbuyle, pcambra, pdenooijer, pdrake, Peacog, Pedro Lozano, pedrop, pefferen, penyaskito, Pepe Roni, pepperstreet, Pere Orga, perusio, petiar, PetrL, peximo, pflame, pfrenssen, pguillard, phenaproxima, phiit, philbar, philipnorton42, philipz, phillamb168, pierregermain, pieterdt, PieterJanPut, pietmarcus, pillarsdotnet, pingers, pingwin4eg, Pinolo, pixelite, pixelwhip, piyuesh23, pjbaert, pjonckiere, pkiraly, plach, Plascual, plopesc, pmackay, pmelab, pminf, podarok, poiu, Pol, polynya, pounard, pp, pplantinga, Pr0v0dn1k, prabhu9484, PrabhuG, prabhurajn654, prajaankit, prasad_gogate, Prashant.c, prashantgoel, prateek479, pratik60, prestonso, prics, prodosh, psynaptic, ptmkenny, purabkharat, pwieck, pwolanin, quicksketch, quietone, quiron, R.Muilwijk, rachel_norfolk, RachFrieee, rachit_gupta, Rafael Cansinos, rahul.shinde, rahuldolas123, RajeevK, Rajesh Ashok, rajeshwari10, rajneeshb, rak2008, rameshbabu.g, ramlev, Ranko, rasskull, ravi.khetri, RavindraSingh, rbayliss, rbmboogie, rbosscher, rbunch, rdickert, rdrh555, realityloop, redndahead, redsd, reekris, reglogge, renat, ressa, reszli, rfay, rgpublic, rhabbachi, ricardoamaro, rickmanelius, rickvug, rkcreation, rkjha, rkoller, rli, rlmumford, roald, robbertnl, robert-os, robertdbailey, robertgarrigos, Roberto Gerola, RobertoGuzman, Robin Millette, Robin Monks, RobLoach, robmc, RobW, rocket_nova, roderik, rodrigoaguilera, RodrigoBalest, RogerRogers, ronald_istos, rooby, roynilanjan, RoySegall, rpayanm, rpsu, rszrama, rteijeiro, rudiedirkx, rudivanes, rupl, russo79, rvilar, rwt, ry5n, ryanissamson, Ryan Weal, rych, sahain, saki007ster, Salazey, salvis, Sam152, sandipmkhairnar, sandykadam, sandzel, Saphyel, saravananr971, sardara, sasanikolic, sashken2, savithac, Sborsody, Schnitzel, scor, scottalan, scristian, sdboyer, sdelbosc, SeanBannister, SeanKelly, SebCorbin, sebi, segi, seiplax, sense-design, Sephi77, seranooo5, sergeypavlenko, serundeputy, Sethie, seutje, sfyn, shabirahmad, Shai, shanethehat, Sharique, Shellingfox, shenzhuxi, shixish, shnark, shuklasp, shwetaneelsharma, Shyamala, siammoney.net, sic, sidharrell, sidharthap, SiliconMind, Sill, silverwing, sime, simolokid, Simon Georges, simply021, sinasalek, sir_squall, SKAUGHT, skippednote, skipyT, skwashd, skyredwang, slashrsm, slowflyer, smiletrl, smithworx, smokris, snufkin, Snugug, socketwench, soipo, Sonal.Sangale, sorressean, Soul88, SoumyaDas, sourcesoft, spacereactor, spearhead93, speely, Spleshka, spoit, Stalski, starchild, stBorchert, steelsector, stefan.r, Stefan Freudenberg, stefank, Stefan Nagtegaal, SteffenR, steinmb, stella, stephen.colson, Steven, Steven Jones, stevepurkiss, stewart.adam, stijndmd, stkrzysiak, stpaultim, StryKaizer, StuartJNCC, subhojit777, sukanya.ramakrishnan, Sumeet.Pareek, sun, sun.core, superspring, surandesilva, surgeonbor, sushantpaste, sushilkr, sushyl, Sutharsan, svdhout, svendecabooter, svenryen, svjuly, SwapS, swastik1608, Sweetchuck, swentel, sxnc, syamnath, sylus, Sylvain Lecoy, sylvain_a, szato, s_leu, T-lo, talhaparacha, tammo, tamnv, tarmstrong, tassilogroeper, tatarbj, tduong, te-brian, tedbow, teroelonen, tetranz, thamas, thechanceg, thedavidmeister, thegreatone, thehong, thePanz, therealssj, theunraveler, Thew, the_phi, ThisIsDog, thlafon, thomas4019, Thomas Factory, Thomas_Zahreddin, thpoul, ti2m, tim-e, tim.plunkett, Tim Bozeman, timmillwood, timofey, tinker, tinyrobot, tkoleary, tky, tloudon, tobiasb, tobiberlin, toemaz, tomreavley, Tom Robert, tomsm, TonyScott, Tor Arne Thune, torpy, TR, TransitionKojo, TravisCarden, trebormc, trevjs, Truptti, tsi, tstoeckler, tsvenson, tucho, tuutti, twistor, TwoD, twomasc, tylernichols, typhonius, Uccio, Ujin, ultimike, underq, unstatu, Upchuk, ursula, vaartio, vacho, vaibhavjain, valdo, valthebald, vaplas, vasi, vasi1186, vasike, vastav, vbouchet, vdanielpop, vegantriathlete, vegardjo, vermario, vg3095, viirak, vijaycs85, Vikas Negi, visabhishek, vlad.dancer, VladSavitsky, vlkff, vodde83, Volker23, vollepeer, voxpelli, vprocessor, vuzzbox, vyasamit2007, vzblk, wadmiraal, walkah, wamilton, weakqueen99, webchick, webcultist, webflo, webkenny, webmozart, webwarrior, westie, WigglyKoala, wilco, WilliamB, willieseabrook, willwh, willyk, willzyx, wilsonw, Wim Leers, wjaspers, wmortada, wmostrey, wojtha, wooody, worldlinemine, WormFood, wrg20, wroxbox, wturrell, wuinfo, wusel, xaav, xadag, xandeadx, Xano, xecstasyx, Xen, ximo, xjm, xmacinfo, xpound, xslim, XTCHost, yang_yi_cn, yanniboi, yannickoo, yannisc, yasenp, yched, YesCT, ygerasimov, yhager, yobottehg, Yogesh Pawar, yohannbzh, yongt9412, yoroy, yraffah, ytsurk, yuREKLI, yurii_2016, yurtboy, z.stolar, zahord, zaporylie, zealfire, ZenDoodles, Zerdiox, zerodeux, zeropx, zestagio, zetagraph, zippydoug, zirvap, zkday, znerol, zolt_toth, Zoltán Balogh, zroger, zschmid, zserno, zsofi.major, ztl8702, zuuperman, _nolocation: Remove multilingual initiative from MAINTAINERS.txt as completed '