As site Admin -> Open Atrium -> Groups: I've a public group made of just three members (tab-members), the site Admin, User 1 and User 2.

User 1 and User 2 appear also as (Group) Administrators (tab-owners) since I promoted them previously (they're promoted beacuse I can see the "Remove as Admin" option on each one drop-down menu when in Group Administrators AND because they're also under the Group Administrators tab) but still they can be (re)added as many time as you want as Admin. Theirs drop-down menus show the option "Add as Admin".

Basically it's possible, without errors from OA which confirms the operation, to set those members as Group Administrator as many times as you want (but to remove them just one).

That's quite curious -> I wouldn't expect to see the "Add as Admin" option if the Group member is yet promoted as Group Administrator exactly as I would expect to see (and I see) the "Remove as Admin" option only if he was yet promoted as Group Administrator...but I could be wrong in expecting such symmetrical behaviour about member's options.

As site member (User 1 or 2), by browsing to "All Groups..." and selecting the above test group, the scenario looks exactly the same as seen as site Admin.

Thanks, Davide.

Comments

hefox’s picture

hefox CreditAttribution: hefox commented
Title: OA Groups: Group's member yet promoted (Group) Adminstrator still shows the "Add as Admin" drop-down menu option. » Under members tab of members page, drop down for admin still show "add as admin" option for group/space admins

Confirmed, but it'd take a bit of code juggling to fix. reading someone as an admin is no-op I think

pmusaraj’s picture

pmusaraj CreditAttribution: pmusaraj commented

I'd be interested in a fix for this as well, and @hefox, I'd happy to look into making a patch for this if you could let me know where the relevant code is.

What would also be useful, would to be be able to add users to other OG roles via this interface, as well as show tabs of members for these additional roles.

pmusaraj’s picture

pmusaraj CreditAttribution: pmusaraj commented

nvm, i found out that this is generated under oa_core_members_widget_render().

dpoletto’s picture

dpoletto CreditAttribution: dpoletto commented

Just an update: this behaviour is still present in OA 2.41.
I would also remember that what reported is basically valid when speaking about Space membership too (so not only speaking about Group membership as initially reported, issue's title is thus quite correct).
Would be great to find a way to graphically/visually "highlight" those users that are promoted as Group/Space Administrators when examining each Group/Space membership pages.

hefox’s picture

hefox CreditAttribution: hefox commented
Version: 7.x-2.33 » 7.x-2.x-dev
Category: Support request » Feature request
mpotter’s picture

mpotter CreditAttribution: mpotter commented

A complete revamp of the Members page is planned later this summery and this will likely be addressed then. Don't worry about trying to make any patches to the existing code.