[META] Tracking WYSIWYG compatibility

works in ckeditor 4.2

Updated issue summary.

working with 4.1.3

updated for #1504696-55: Integration with CKEditor module

ckeditor.module w/ 4.03 library working

Updated issue summary.

test for 4.1.3 added

tests for WYSIWYG with CKEditor 4.0.3 updated

Tests with wysiwyg.module and CKeditor library 4.2 and wysiwyg.module show the embed code being inserted into the source, but embed does not show in WYSIWYG.
- Saving node with the WYSIWYG turned off shows the rendered media correctly on node view.
- Returning to the node to edit it shows no media embed in the WYSIWYG and the embed code is stripped from the source.

Tests with wysiwyg.module and CKeditor library 4.1.3 show the same results at 4.2 mentioned in #1

Tests with wysiwyg.module and CKeditor library 4.0.3 show the media insert working as expected!

Tests with ckeditor.module and CKEditor library 3.6.6.1, 4.0.3, 4.1.3 and 4.2 are working with patch from #1504696-55: Integration with CKEditor module

#1 is likely because #1956778: Ckeditor 4.1 ACF - this also affects TinyMCE 4

formatting fix

add tinymce tests

formatting

Tests with wysiwyg.module and TinyMCE version 4.0.3 are inconclusive as WYSIWYG has not been updated to support this version of the library. See: #1968318: Support for TinyMCE 4.x

Tests with wysiwyg.module and TinyMCE version 3.5.8 show the media insert working as expected.

FWIW, I tested this too and got it working with all 3 versions of CKE as well.

DOCUMENTATION for integration of media with wysiwyg

Integration is working very well wysiwyg.module. Will be useful to link http://alligatorsneeze.com/image-uploads-using-wysiwyg-and-media-drupal-7-0 for documentation on integration of media with wysiwyg,

Is anyone actually having any issues with Media in TinyMCE 4? I can no longer reproduce the issues I had with the media placeholder getting filtered out.

In testing a fresh install of the media_dev install profile, I've noticed a few issues with wysiwg module + ckeditor 3.6.6.1:

When I do a new embed, I noticed that it puts in the following token markup:
[[{"fid":"1","view_mode":"teaser","fields":{"format":"teaser","field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]":"woo alt","field_file_image_title_text[und][0][value]":"woo title","media_description[und][0][value]":""},"type":"media","attributes":{}}]]<!--MEDIA-WRAPPER-END-1-->
Is there supposed to be a <!--MEDIA-WRAPPER-START-1-->? If so, am I missing something?

wysiwyg.module + CKEditor 3.6.6.1 with new Drupal install and the latest file entity/media modules:
When creating a new image embed using the default or preview view modes, the embed works correctly and reselecting the image highlights the Add media button correctly. When clicked, it opens the edit media form.

However, if at any time (initial embed or editing an embed) I choose the teaser display, save the embed, and reselect the image, the Add media button is no longer selected and clicking it bring up the Upload interface, instead of the edit form.

Taking a look at the media token, it has added a second !--MEDIA-WRAPPER-END-1--> comment.
<p>[[{"fid":"1","view_mode":"teaser","fields":{"format":"teaser","field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]":"alt","field_file_image_title_text[und][0][value]":"title"},"type":"media","attributes":{}}]]<!--MEDIA-WRAPPER-END-1--><!--MEDIA-WRAPPER-END-1--></p>

If I select the image and delete it, both the comments are still in the WYSIWYG: <p><!--MEDIA-WRAPPER-END-1--><!--MEDIA-WRAPPER-END-1--></p>

If, at any time you want me to recreate these as individual issues, I'd be more than happy to.

Followup for comment #11:
I noticed that on File Types > Image > Manage File Displays, for the Image display settings, the "Link image to" field was set to Content instead of Nothing, like the other view modes. Setting it to nothing and then testing the embeds again the Add media button is highlighted when selecting the image and the edit form opens in the modal. So this leads me to believe the button and media wrapper issues are related to how the link is being handled.

Setting the link to File results in the same issue.

Found #2067873: The image 'Teaser' file display linking to Content causes issues when being used in WYSIWYG which addresses part of comment #11.

wrong comment #

Added related issues

Added new CKEditor version 4.3.

Wysiwyg-dev and Media-2-dev with CKeditor 4.1.2 does not work at all. If you save the node or switch the editor on/off, it changes to 'false'.

Fixed a typoo in the title.

Is there an update on the version / patch requirements? Is there a working combination for CKeditor 4.4.x ? With CKeditor Module and Media dev?

@marcusx - see: #2159403: Make CKEditor plugin system modular and clean

Closing this issue as outdated. However, if you think this issue is still important, please let us know and we will gladly re-open it for review.
sincerely,
- the Drupal Media Team